FOF Top 30 Community Voting—2024 Post-Trade Deadline Edition

[Ely Sussman]

Sooooo much has changed about this Miami Marlins farm system since we previously opened up community voting during spring training. Thanks to everybody who submitted their own rankings below! (here is the official Fish On First Top 30 for comparison's sake)

 

---

 

Combined Top 30 List

1. Thomas White
2. Noble Meyer
3. Agustín Ramírez
4. Connor Norby
5. Deyvison De Los Santos
6. Robby Snelling
7. Carter Johnson
8. Jared Serna
9. Dillon Head
10. PJ Morlando
11. Adam Mazur
12. Victor Mesa Jr.
13. Andrés Valor
14. Javier Sanoja
15. Joe Mack
16. Luis Cova
17. Dax Fulton
18. Juan De La Cruz
19. Karson Milbrandt
20. Aiden May
21. Graham Pauley
22. Jakob Marsee
23. Eliazar Dishmey
24. Andrew Pintar
25. Jacob Miller
26. Jun-Seok Shim
27. Kemp Alderman
28. Grant Shepardson
29. Keyner Benitez
30. Jacob Berry

We will do another round of voting after the 2024 season concludes.

[Ely Sussman]

1. Thomas White
2. Agustín Ramírez
3. Deyvison De Los Santos
4. Connor Norby
5. Noble Meyer
6. Carter Johnson
7. Robby Snelling
8. Victor Mesa Jr.
9. Dillon Head
10. Jared Serna
11. Adam Mazur
12. Andrés Valor
13. Javier Sanoja
14. PJ Morlando
15. Joe Mack
16. Dax Fulton
17. Luis Cova
18. Jakob Marsee
19. Juan De La Cruz
20. Andrew Pintar
21. Aiden May
22. Jacob Miller
23. Eliazar Dishmey
24. Karson Milbrandt
25. Graham Pauley
26. Kemp Alderman
27. Jun-Seok Shim
28. Nigel Belgrave
29. Gage Miller
30. Valente Bellozo

The gap between Thomas White and every other prospect in the Marlins system is substantial.

The prospects who just missed cracking my Top 30 are Josh Ekness, Keyner Benitez and Will Banfield.

[Drillyamama]

1. Thomas White
2. Noble Meyer
3. Robby Snelling
4. Agustín Ramírez
5. Carter Johnson
6. Connor Norby
7. PJ Morlando
8. Deyvison De Los Santos
9. Jared Serna
10. Joe Mack
11. Dillon Head
12. Adam Mazur
13. Javier Sanoja
14. Eliazar Dishmey
15. Victor Mesa Jr.
16. Aiden May
17. Luis Cova
18. Jun-Seok Shim
19. Gage Miller
20. Andrés Valor
21. Jacob Miller
22. Graham Pauley
23. Karson Milbrandt
24. Wilfredo Lara
25. Grant Shepardson
26. Jakob Marsee
27. Juan De La Cruz
28. Kemp Alderman
29. Nigel Belgrave
30. Ryan Ignoffo

[Reice]

1. Thomas White
2. Noble Meyer
3. Robby Snelling
4. Agustín Ramírez
5. Eliazar Dishmey
6. Connor Norby
7. Deyvison De Los Santos
8. Carter Johnson
9. Luis Cova
10. Jared Serna
11. PJ Morlando
12. Dillon Head
13. Andrés Valor
14. Victor Mesa Jr.
15. Joe Mack
16. Dax Fulton
17. Javier Sanoja
18. Adam Mazur
19. Graham Pauley
20. Keyner Benitez
21. Karson Milbrandt
22. Juan De La Cruz
23. Kemp Alderman
24. Jun-Seok Shim
25. Andrew Pintar
26. Jakob Marsee
27. Aiden May
28. Jacob Miller
29. Grant Shepardson
30. Ryan Ignoffo

[Alexhoss23]

1. Josh Simpson
2. Troy Johnston
3. Connor Norby
4. Noble Meyer
5. Thomas White
6. Agustín Ramírez
7. Deyvison De Los Santos
8. Carter Johnson
9. Jared Serna
10. Robby Snelling
11. Griffin Conine
12. Victor Mesa Jr.
13. Adam Mazur
14. Dillon Head
15. Andrés Valor
16. PJ Morlando
17. Joe Mack
18. Dax Fulton
19. Javier Sanoja
20. Luis Cova
21. Karson Milbrandt
22. Juan De La Cruz
23. Jakob Marsee
24. Andrew Pintar
25. Aiden May
26. Jacob Miller
27. Eliazar Dishmey
28. Graham Pauley
29. Jun-Seok Shim
30. Anthony Maldonado

[Breezy]

1. Thomas White
2. Agustín Ramírez
3. Noble Meyer
4. Deyvison De Los Santos
5. Robby Snelling
6. Connor Norby
7. Jared Serna
8. Carter Johnson
9. Dillon Head
10. Victor Mesa Jr.
11. PJ Morlando
12. Andrés Valor
13. Joe Mack
14. Luis Cova
15. Adam Mazur
16. Javier Sanoja
17. Aiden May
18. Graham Pauley
19. Juan De La Cruz
20. Jun-Seok Shim
21. Dax Fulton
22. Karson Milbrandt
23. Jakob Marsee
24. Valente Bellozo
25. Eliazar Dishmey
26. Andrew Pintar
27. Kemp Alderman
28. Jacob Miller
29. Nathan Martorella
30. Jacob Berry

[swk473]

1. Thomas White
2. Noble Meyer
3. Carter Johnson
4. Agustín Ramírez
5. Deyvison De Los Santos
6. Jared Serna
7. Robby Snelling
8. Adam Mazur
9. PJ Morlando
10. Dillon Head
11. Javier Sanoja
12. Juan De La Cruz
13. Connor Norby
14. Graham Pauley
15. Luis Cova
16. Andrés Valor
17. Andrew Pintar
18. Aiden May
19. Victor Mesa Jr.
20. Jun-Seok Shim
21. Keyner Benitez
22. Grant Shepardson
23. Josh Ekness
24. Jacob Miller
25. Wilfredo Lara
26. Valente Bellozo
27. Fenwick Trimble
28. Dax Fulton
29. Eliazar Dishmey
30. Jakob Marsee

[IanBroyles]

1. Noble Meyer
2. Thomas White
3. Connor Norby
4. Deyvison De Los Santos
5. Agustín Ramírez
6. Carter Johnson
7. Jared Serna
8. Robby Snelling
9. Victor Mesa Jr.
10. Dillon Head
11. PJ Morlando
12. Adam Mazur
13. Andrés Valor
14. Joe Mack
15. Dax Fulton
16. Javier Sanoja
17. Luis Cova
18. Juan De La Cruz
19. Karson Milbrandt
20. Jakob Marsee
21. Andrew Pintar
22. Aiden May
23. Jacob Miller
24. Eliazar Dishmey
25. Jun-Seok Shim
26. Graham Pauley
27. Grant Shepardson
28. Ryan Ignoffo
29. Josh Ekness
30. Yiddi Cappe

[Jhulgzz]

1. Thomas White
2. Noble Meyer
3. Connor Norby
4. Carter Johnson
5. Jared Serna
6. Agustín Ramírez
7. Deyvison De Los Santos
8. Jacob Berry
9. Robby Snelling
10. Dillon Head
11. Joe Mack
12. Adam Mazur
13. Victor Mesa Jr.
14. Andrés Valor
15. PJ Morlando
16. Luis Cova
17. Javier Sanoja
18. Jakob Marsee
19. Dax Fulton
20. Karson Milbrandt
21. Graham Pauley
22. Andrew Pintar
23. Juan De La Cruz
24. Aiden May
25. Jacob Miller
26. Eliazar Dishmey
27. Jun-Seok Shim
28. Grant Shepardson
29. Ryan Ignoffo
30. Nathan Martorella

[Sean McCormack]

1. Thomas White
2. Noble Meyer
3. Robby Snelling
4. Carter Johnson
5. Deyvison De Los Santos
6. Connor Norby
7. Agustín Ramírez
8. Adam Mazur
9. Javier Sanoja
10. Dillon Head
11. PJ Morlando
12. Jared Serna
13. Graham Pauley
14. Kemp Alderman
15. Andrés Valor
16. Luis Cova
17. Jakob Marsee
18. Joe Mack
19. Eliazar Dishmey
20. Victor Mesa Jr.
21. Karson Milbrandt
22. Wilfredo Lara
23. Dax Fulton
24. Jacob Miller
25. Juan De La Cruz
26. Andrew Pintar
27. Aiden May
28. Jun-Seok Shim
29. Grant Shepardson
30. Josh Ekness

[ErikC10]

1. Noble Meyer
2. Thomas White
3. Agustín Ramírez
4. Deyvison De Los Santos
5. Jared Serna
6. Robby Snelling
7. Connor Norby
8. Carter Johnson
9. Adam Mazur
10. Victor Mesa Jr.
11. PJ Morlando
12. Javier Sanoja
13. Joe Mack
14. Luis Cova
15. Dillon Head
16. Kemp Alderman
17. Andrés Valor
18. Dax Fulton
19. Karson Milbrandt
20. Andrew Pintar
21. Aiden May
22. Jacob Miller
23. Jun-Seok Shim
24. Jakob Marsee
25. Eliazar Dishmey
26. Juan De La Cruz
27. Grant Shepardson
28. Graham Pauley
29. Ryan Ignoffo
30. Josh Ekness

[Chad Turner]

1. Thomas White
2. Deyvison De Los Santos
   44 HR, over .300 avg mostly as a 20 yr old in AA and AAA over the last 13 months. I'm on the DLS train!!!
3. Noble Meyer
4. Connor Norby
5. Agustín Ramírez
6. Robby Snelling
7. Dillon Head
8. Carter Johnson
9. PJ Morlando
10. Adam Mazur
11. Victor Mesa Jr.
12. Javier Sanoja
    How can you put him behind Serna? He's younger and in AAA all year. The bat, speed, and D are similar. Plus Sanoja plays CF too.
13. Jared Serna
14. Andrés Valor
15. Jacob Berry
16. Karson Milbrandt
17. Joe Mack
18. Graham Pauley
19. Dax Fulton
20. Jakob Marsee
21. Luis Cova
22. Keyner Benitez
    He's 1.4 years younger than JDLC and got called up to A two months before him. Perhaps JDLC has more velo but my age/level method rarely fails.
23. Juan De La Cruz
24. Andrew Pintar
25. Aiden May
26. Jacob Miller
27. Jun-Seok Shim
28. Eliazar Dishmey
29. Ryan Ignoffo
30. Nigel Belgrave

Abrahan Ramirez?

[Jaccosta05]

1. Thomas White
2. Agustín Ramírez
3. Noble Meyer
4. Connor Norby
5. Robby Snelling
6. Luis Cova
7. Deyvison De Los Santos
8. Dillon Head
9. Carter Johnson
10. Jared Serna
11. Victor Mesa Jr.
12. Andrés Valor
13. Joe Mack
14. PJ Morlando
15. Adam Mazur
16. Juan De La Cruz
17. Jakob Marsee
18. Jun-Seok Shim
19. Eliazar Dishmey
20. Dax Fulton
21. Javier Sanoja
22. Karson Milbrandt
23. Aiden May
24. Jacob Miller
25. Graham Pauley
26. Grant Shepardson
27. Ryan Ignoffo
28. Josh Ekness
29. Nigel Belgrave
30. Kemp Alderman

[M.J.S]

1. Thomas White
2. Agustín Ramírez
3. Connor Norby
4. Noble Meyer
5. Carter Johnson
6. Jared Serna
7. Deyvison De Los Santos
8. Robby Snelling
9. Adam Mazur
10. Dillon Head
11. PJ Morlando
12. Andrés Valor
13. Victor Mesa Jr.
14. Joe Mack
15. Dax Fulton
16. Javier Sanoja
17. Luis Cova
18. Juan De La Cruz
19. Karson Milbrandt
20. Jakob Marsee
21. Andrew Pintar
22. Aiden May
23. Eliazar Dishmey
24. Jacob Miller
25. Graham Pauley
26. Jun-Seok Shim
27. Grant Shepardson
28. Kemp Alderman
29. Josh Ekness
30. Valente Bellozo

[mpicardi]

1. Thomas White
2. Agustín Ramírez
3. Connor Norby
4. Noble Meyer
5. Jared Serna
6. Deyvison De Los Santos
7. Robby Snelling
8. Adam Mazur
9. Dillon Head
10. Carter Johnson
11. Victor Mesa Jr.
12. Javier Sanoja
13. PJ Morlando
14. Andrés Valor
15. Joe Mack
16. Dax Fulton
17. Graham Pauley
18. Luis Cova
19. Karson Milbrandt
20. Juan De La Cruz
21. Aiden May
22. Jakob Marsee
23. Kemp Alderman
24. Andrew Pintar
25. Jun-Seok Shim
    By this time next year if we get a full season from Shim, he could shoot up like 15 spots. Biggest helium candidate in the system.
26. Grant Shepardson
27. Jacob Miller
28. Josh Ekness
29. Nigel Belgrave
30. Ryan Ignoffo

[SouthKoreanFan]

1. Thomas White
   Most valuable prospect from our team now Polished guy for his age and can be and frontline starter
2. Noble Meyer
   I think he has electric stuff but need to be developed more... Still young and has enugh upside
3. Agustín Ramírez
   Huge raw power bat with questionable defense... Has similar tool as Deyvinson if he goes 1b/of but he's catcher at least now and I'll rank him here for his position
4. Connor Norby
   He can hit and has power, but his strikeout rate concerns me somehow But he can play 2b/3b/of and at least he can be utility guy with bomds
5. Carter Johnson
   Some guys said that he can be Gunner Henderson 2.0 and I also agree with that opinion Has good skills and if he can stick on SS, we can see his name on MLB Top 100 prospects next year
6. Robby Snelling
   Having bad year after amazing 2023 season but I believe he can rebound by our pitching staffs who developed many good pitchers
7. Deyvison De Los Santos
   Enjoying impact season this year and still 21, but I concern about him for that we can believe all his humbers by itself and his impatience at bat. Mark Trumbo/Dayan Viciedo type player he can be I think
8. Jared Serna
   I'm high on propects who's showing good results than expected ceiling, and he's a real guy besides of his phyisical in my opinion. He can hit, has power and can be stick as center infielder.
9. Victor Mesa Jr.
   He's always matched up with the guys over his age and did good job for sure But I think he can show more than he's doing now
10. Javier Sanoja
    Similar as Serna, he's showing really great job than evaluations and he can be a really good utility guy at least Maybe can be Xavier Edward 2.0?
11. Dillon Head
    We got this toolsy, loud young bat from Padres and he can be 5-tool guy I think But he needs to be healthy enough
12. Andrés Valor
    He made good numbers even he came over to US (Many international signees usually blocked by wall at first when they came into US) He can run, has power and can be our center fielder of future if he continues to develop as now
13. PJ Morlando
    I like him for his enthusiasm and power that he has, but sadly he just injured after just a game after his debut Wish he can make good result next year
14. Joe Mack
    Most developed guy from our farm this year Has power and can easily stick as backstop but I'm still concerned little about his bat-to-ball skills
15. Adam Mazur
    He'll be a good big league rotation guy but he's going to be 3/4 spot I think Don't see him as frontliner if he does just as now
16. Dax Fulton
    Huge upside guy, but he's injured
17. Luis Cova
    Our most expensive signee for 2024 international class and doing well on DSL I can see him play FCL next year and his stock to be skyrocketed
18. Juan De La Cruz
    Has raw upside but need to be developed more for sure
19. Jacob Miller
    He's showing nice floor, but I wish his velocity goes back as he was drafted
20. Aiden May
    Some scouts compared our CBB pick as Spencer Strider 2.0 and I also wish him to be like that
21. Keyner Benitez
    Nice young pitcher with upside for sure
22. Grant Shepardson
    Really good pick of our Day 2 draft by many writers, and I'm also high on him
23. Andrew Pintar
    Polished guy with rare speed/power combination, and he also has good place discipline
24. Eliazar Dishmey
    Shows good numbers and I see him on our rotation at 2026/2027
25. Kemp Alderman
    He has good power and still shows what he can do when he promoted to Hi-A Kinda Peyton Burdick type player maybe?
26. Jun-Seok Shim
    I saw him since he was high school at South Korea(he was once no.1 draftee candidate for sure), and he has really good stuff but he's too injury-prone and really need to be healthy
27. Ryan Ignoffo
    I'm high on this coverted-catcher and he can hit! If he can stay backstop, I think he can be next Austin Nola (whom we lost too early)
28. Wilfredo Lara
    He's sneaky good player we got from trade deadline and I see him as 5-tool player Young and versatile makes him valuable
29. Graham Pauley
    He showed good moments last year at Padres but stuggled a lot and I just see him as utility player who can hit
30. Fabian López
    Speedy and defensive guy, but his bat is questionable I expect him as Nasim Nunez and need to prove more at bat as he's still too young

Tried to comment as intersted person from South Korea

(Have been cheered this team since 2011 and still it's too harsh to be fan of Marlins when it goes seasonal rebuilding;;)

All coments at the propects are just my opinion so please be little bit generous if you have different thoughts

[Malman123]

1. Noble Meyer
2. Thomas White
3. Robby Snelling
4. Deyvison De Los Santos
5. Agustín Ramírez
6. Connor Norby
7. Jared Serna
8. PJ Morlando
9. Carter Johnson
10. Adam Mazur
11. Victor Mesa Jr.
12. Andrés Valor
13. Javier Sanoja
14. Joe Mack
15. Jacob Miller
16. Dax Fulton
17. Luis Cova
18. Andrew Pintar
19. Karson Milbrandt
20. Dillon Head
21. Juan De La Cruz
22. Jakob Marsee
23. Aiden May
24. Eliazar Dishmey
25. Graham Pauley
26. Jun-Seok Shim
27. Grant Shepardson
28. Valente Bellozo
29. Kemp Alderman
30. Ryan Ignoffo