FOF Top 30 Community Voting—2024 Preseason Edition

[Ely Sussman]

Here's who you think the top prospects in the Miami Marlins organization are entering the 2024 season.

Ranked Prospects

1. Noble Meyer
2. Thomas White
3. Max Meyer
4. Victor Mesa Jr.
5. Luis Cova
6. Xavier Edwards
7. Dax Fulton
8. Jacob Amaya
9. Troy Johnston
10. Yiddi Cappe
11. Karson Milbrandt
12. Andrés Valor
13. Dane Myers
14. Jacob Berry
15. Patrick Monteverde
16. Jacob Miller
17. Juan De La Cruz
18. Anthony Maldonado
19. Will Banfield
20. Kemp Alderman
21. Josh Simpson
22. Javier Sanoja
23. Fabian López
24. Jancory De La Cruz
25. Brock Vradenburg
26. Tristan Gray
27. José Castro
28. Evan Fitterer
29. Sixto Sánchez
30. Ike Buxton

[Nate Karzmer]

1. Noble Meyer
2. Thomas White
3. Luis Cova
4. Victor Mesa Jr.
5. Max Meyer
6. Xavier Edwards
7. Dax Fulton
8. Troy Johnston
9. Yiddi Cappe
10. Jacob Amaya
11. Karson Milbrandt
12. Andrés Valor
13. Jacob Miller
14. Dane Myers
15. Patrick Monteverde
16. Jacob Berry
17. Juan De La Cruz
18. Anthony Maldonado
19. Will Banfield
20. Kemp Alderman
21. Jancory De La Cruz
22. Fabian López
23. Josh Simpson
24. Javier Sanoja
25. José Castro
26. Tristan Gray
27. Paul McIntosh
28. Joe Mack
29. José Devers
30. Brock Vradenburg

[ngast]

1. Noble Meyer
2. Max Meyer
3. Thomas White
4. Victor Mesa Jr.
5. Patrick Monteverde
6. Luis Cova
7. Yiddi Cappe
8. Xavier Edwards
9. Troy Johnston
10. Dax Fulton
11. Jacob Berry
12. Jacob Amaya
13. Karson Milbrandt
14. Andrés Valor
15. Dane Myers
16. Jacob Miller
17. Will Banfield
18. Anthony Maldonado
19. Josh Simpson
20. Tristan Gray
21. Jancory De La Cruz
22. Javier Sanoja
23. Fabian López
24. Brock Vradenburg
25. Kemp Alderman
26. Juan De La Cruz
27. José Castro
28. José Paulino
29. Evan Fitterer
30. Paul McIntosh

[Sean McCormack]

1. Noble Meyer
2. Max Meyer
3. Thomas White
4. Dax Fulton
5. Luis Cova
6. Victor Mesa Jr.
7. Troy Johnston
8. Xavier Edwards
9. Jacob Amaya
10. Patrick Monteverde
11. Javier Sanoja
12. Brock Vradenburg
13. Ike Buxton
14. Jacob Berry
15. Juan De La Cruz
16. Dane Myers
17. Kemp Alderman
18. Karson Milbrandt
19. Jacob Miller
20. Will Banfield
21. Andrés Valor
22. Emmett Olson
23. Anthony Maldonado
24. Nigel Belgrave
25. José Castro
26. José Paulino
27. Josh Simpson
28. Tristan Gray
29. Evan Fitterer
30. Paul McIntosh

[Marlins Guy]

1. Noble Meyer
2. Thomas White
3. Max Meyer
4. Luis Cova
5. Victor Mesa Jr.
6. Xavier Edwards
7. Yiddi Cappe
8. Troy Johnston
9. Dax Fulton
10. Jacob Berry
11. Jacob Amaya
12. Dane Myers
13. Karson Milbrandt
14. Andrés Valor
15. Jacob Miller
16. Will Banfield
17. Patrick Monteverde
18. Josh Simpson
19. Kemp Alderman
20. Tristan Gray
21. Anthony Maldonado
22. Evan Fitterer
23. José Devers
24. Juan De La Cruz
25. Fabian López
26. Paul McIntosh
27. José Castro
28. Ian Lewis
29. Joe Mack
30. Sixto Sánchez

[Austin Lodge]

1. Noble Meyer
2. Thomas White
3. Max Meyer
4. Victor Mesa Jr.
5. Luis Cova
6. Xavier Edwards
7. Jacob Amaya
8. Dax Fulton
9. Yiddi Cappe
10. Troy Johnston
11. Karson Milbrandt
12. Andrés Valor
13. Dane Myers
14. Patrick Monteverde
15. Juan De La Cruz
16. Jacob Miller
17. Anthony Maldonado
18. Josh Simpson
19. Will Banfield
20. Jancory De La Cruz
21. Fabian López
22. Jacob Berry
23. Javier Sanoja
24. Kemp Alderman
25. José Castro
26. José Paulino
27. Evan Fitterer
28. Paul McIntosh
29. José Devers
30. Tristan Gray

[Drillyamama]

1. Noble Meyer
2. Thomas White
3. Max Meyer
4. Luis Cova
5. Victor Mesa Jr.
6. Andrés Valor
7. Troy Johnston
8. Karson Milbrandt
9. Dane Myers
10. Dax Fulton
11. Xavier Edwards
12. Ike Buxton
13. Jacob Amaya
14. Yiddi Cappe
15. Jacob Berry
16. Patrick Monteverde
17. Anthony Maldonado
18. Juan De La Cruz
19. Jacob Miller
20. Kemp Alderman
21. Will Banfield
22. Josh Simpson
23. Fabian López
24. Brock Vradenburg
25. Evan Fitterer
26. Javier Sanoja
27. Tristan Gray
28. Xavier Meachem
29. Luarbert Arias
30. Paul McIntosh

[Ryan Schlesinger]

1. Noble Meyer
2. Max Meyer
3. Thomas White
4. Victor Mesa Jr.
5. Xavier Edwards
6. Luis Cova
7. Yiddi Cappe
8. Troy Johnston
9. Jacob Amaya
10. Dax Fulton
11. Karson Milbrandt
12. Andrés Valor
13. Dane Myers
14. Tristan Gray
15. Patrick Monteverde
16. Juan De La Cruz
17. Anthony Maldonado
18. Jacob Berry
19. Jacob Miller
20. Josh Simpson
21. Will Banfield
22. Jancory De La Cruz
23. Fabian López
24. Javier Sanoja
25. Kemp Alderman
26. José Castro
27. José Paulino
28. Evan Fitterer
29. Paul McIntosh
30. José Devers

[Ben Lehtola]

1. Noble Meyer
2. Thomas White
3. Max Meyer
4. Victor Mesa Jr.
5. Luis Cova
6. Xavier Edwards
7. Dax Fulton
8. Jacob Amaya
9. Yiddi Cappe
10. Troy Johnston
11. Karson Milbrandt
12. Andrés Valor
13. Dane Myers
14. Jacob Berry
15. Patrick Monteverde
16. Juan De La Cruz
17. Anthony Maldonado
18. Jacob Miller
19. Josh Simpson
20. Will Banfield
21. Jancory De La Cruz
22. Fabian López
23. Javier Sanoja
24. José Paulino
25. Kemp Alderman
26. José Castro
27. Evan Fitterer
28. Tristan Gray
29. Paul McIntosh
30. José Devers

[RonCox]

1. Noble Meyer
2. Thomas White
3. Max Meyer
4. Victor Mesa Jr.
5. Luis Cova
6. Xavier Edwards
7. Jacob Amaya
8. Dax Fulton
9. Will Banfield
10. Troy Johnston
11. Karson Milbrandt
12. Andrés Valor
13. Dane Myers
14. Yiddi Cappe
15. Javier Sanoja
16. Jacob Berry
17. Patrick Monteverde
18. Juan De La Cruz
19. Jacob Miller
20. Anthony Maldonado
21. Kemp Alderman
22. Jancory De La Cruz
23. Josh Simpson
24. Fabian López
25. José Castro
26. José Paulino
27. Evan Fitterer
28. Paul McIntosh
29. José Devers
30. Tristan Gray

[Reice]

1. Noble Meyer
2. Max Meyer
3. Thomas White
4. Luis Cova
5. Xavier Edwards
6. Victor Mesa Jr.
7. Jacob Amaya
8. Dax Fulton
9. Troy Johnston
10. Yiddi Cappe
11. Dane Myers
12. Karson Milbrandt
13. Andrés Valor
14. Jacob Berry
15. Patrick Monteverde
16. Juan De La Cruz
17. Jacob Miller
18. Anthony Maldonado
19. Will Banfield
20. Josh Simpson
21. Jancory De La Cruz
22. Fabian López
23. Paul McIntosh
24. Javier Sanoja
25. Kemp Alderman
26. Ike Buxton
27. Evan Fitterer
28. Luarbert Arias
29. Xavier Meachem
30. Torin Montgomery

[Chad Turner]

1. Noble Meyer
2. Thomas White
3. Max Meyer
4. Xavier Edwards
5. Victor Mesa Jr.
6. Dax Fulton
7. Jacob Amaya
8. Troy Johnston
9. Jacob Berry
10. Luis Cova
11. Karson Milbrandt
12. Yiddi Cappe
13. Andrés Valor
14. Dane Myers
15. Jacob Miller
16. Patrick Monteverde
17. Kemp Alderman
18. Juan De La Cruz
19. Will Banfield
20. Fabian López
21. Anthony Maldonado
22. Javier Sanoja
23. Brock Vradenburg
24. José Devers
25. Sixto Sánchez
26. Joe Mack
27. Yoffry Solano
28. Torin Montgomery
29. Luarbert Arias
30. Nigel Belgrave

[Gambit]

1. Noble Meyer
   60+ FV
2. Thomas White
   55+ FV
3. Max Meyer
   55+ FV
4. Dax Fulton
   50+ FV
5. Victor Mesa Jr.
   50+ FV
6. Xavier Edwards
   50 FV
7. Jacob Berry
   45+ FV
8. Luis Cova
   50+ FV
9. Sixto Sánchez
   50+
10. Karson Milbrandt
    45+
11. Brock Vradenburg
    45+ FV
12. Andrés Valor
    45+ FV
13. Yiddi Cappe
    45+ FV
14. Jacob Miller
    45+ FV
15. Troy Johnston
    45 FV
16. Jacob Amaya
    45 FV
17. Kemp Alderman
    40+ FV
18. Dane Myers
    40+ FV
19. Juan De La Cruz
    40+ FV
20. Anthony Maldonado
    40+ FV
21. Fabian López
    40+ FV
22. Patrick Monteverde
    40 FV
23. Will Banfield
    40 FV
24. Joe Mack
    40+ FV
25. Javier Sanoja
    40 FV
26. Xavier Meachem
    40 FV
27. Evan Fitterer
    40 FV
28. Mark Coley II
    40 FV
29. Yoffry Solano
    40+ FV
30. Emmett Olson
    40 FV

[Slacker Mills]

1. Noble Meyer
   He's shown nothing. I'd say mid teens.
2. Thomas White
   No. 4 prospect
3. Max Meyer
   number 2
4. Victor Mesa Jr.
   out of top ten
5. Luis Cova
   know nothing about him
6. Xavier Edwards
   Clear number one
7. Jacob Amaya
   no longer a serious prospect
8. Dax Fulton
   top five - he showed lots of potential in AA
9. Yiddi Cappe
   about ten
10. Troy Johnston
    top ten
11. Karson Milbrandt
12. Andrés Valor
13. Dane Myers
    top ten
14. Jacob Berry
15. Patrick Monteverde
    top 15
16. Juan De La Cruz
17. Jacob Miller
18. Anthony Maldonado
19. Josh Simpson
20. Will Banfield
    top ten
21. Jancory De La Cruz
22. Fabian López
23. Javier Sanoja
24. Kemp Alderman
25. José Castro
26. José Paulino
27. Evan Fitterer
28. Paul McIntosh
29. José Devers
30. Tristan Gray

[Seth Stohs]

1. Noble Meyer
2. Thomas White
3. Max Meyer
4. Victor Mesa Jr.
5. Dax Fulton
6. Luis Cova
7. Xavier Edwards
8. Jacob Amaya
9. Yiddi Cappe
10. Joe Mack
11. Jacob Berry
12. Troy Johnston
13. Karson Milbrandt
14. Andrés Valor
15. Dane Myers
16. Patrick Monteverde
17. Sixto Sánchez
18. Juan De La Cruz
19. Jacob Miller
20. Anthony Maldonado
21. Josh Simpson
22. Will Banfield
23. Jancory De La Cruz
24. Fabian López
25. Javier Sanoja
26. Kemp Alderman
27. José Castro
28. José Paulino
29. Evan Fitterer
30. Paul McIntosh

Go Joe Mack!! 

[Slacker Mills]

Didn't know that Sanchez was still eligible so I'd put him Number One. The added benefit here is that the Marlins will have him for Pre Arb money for the next three years (which will hopefully be his prime).

[Slacker Mills]

It doesn't pay to accept the words of others when it comes to judging prospects.. I put White at three and Noble Meyer in the teens as a result of personal observation. Today, White was an easy 96 with control of the occasional off-speed stuff. Meyer sat at a very hittable 92-93 with little control. The two aren't close as prospects at this point.Teel should have been the Marlins top pick.