Jump to content
Fish On First
  • Create Account

Sean Millerick

Fish On First Editor
  • Posts

    171
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    9

Sean Millerick last won the day on November 12

Sean Millerick had the most liked content!

Recent Profile Visitors

The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.

Sean Millerick's Achievements

  1. Do MLB players want to play for the Miami Marlins? As another offseason gets underway, the same old question returns for fans of the league's southernmost franchise. For much of their history—certainly much of this century—the answer has been a resounding no. To be fair, it's been hard to blame them. While the game is a business first and foremost, winning and stability still count for plenty. Those are things that have seldom been on the menu for Marlins players. Throw in an empty ballpark, and it's just a tough sell for free agents. Thus, the existence of what I've come to call the Marlins Tax. The unfortunate reality where the Marlins are forced to pay well above market value for likely below average talent. In other words, Miami is doubly penalized when they turn to free agency. Have the Marlins finally graduated from needing to pay it? The answer to that question will only define their entire offseason. Fortunately for Marlins fans, there's a compelling case to be made that the answer is yes. The team has gotten better for three straight seasons, and the expectation in baseball circles is for that trend to continue in 2027. The vibes are strong in Miami under the watch of team president Peter Bendix, even if Bruce Sherman remains the owner. And even Sherman has drawn some kudos for his investment in the team''s spring training facility, as well as the organization's Dominican Academy. The Marlins have a young core and a solid farm system. There's a lot to recommend. Could it be that players now regard South Florida the same way they do St. Petersburg? A smart, savvy organization committed to winning? Unfortunately, I'm still inclined to say the answer is no. The Tax still applies. As with everything else you're going to hear this offseason, it all comes down to payroll, and the Marlins did just spend another season in the cellar moneywise. Fairly or not, the Marlins continue to be tagged for spending in a way the Rays are not, and that will continue to be the case until the Marlins have their own pile of playoff appearances to point towards. The jury is also still very much out on how players view Miami's unorthodox changes the past two seasons, namely calling pitches from the dugout and using starters as relievers on pitch design days. One man's shrewd winning strategy is another's penny pinching necessity. However, two things could flip the script for the Marlins very quickly. Firstly, extensions. A single big name extension could be enough to convince players that Miami really is serious about consistently competing. Putting some money behind their core would send a clear message to free agents that the window is open. What pitcher wouldn't want to know they could count on having Joe Mack as a battery-mate? What player wouldn't want to play alongside a teammate like Sandy Alcantara, or a talent like Eury Perez? Secondly, and this is the wild card, do players believe that salary reform is coming to MLB? If the answer is yes? Then the Marlins suddenly become much more like the Dolphins, Heat, and Panthers, able to sell sunshine and lack of income tax to entice players to come here. In which case, the Marlins Tax is gone. If the answer is no? Then Miami remains as merely possibly preferable to Pittsburgh, at least until they prove they can be counted on to compete. Until which time the Marlins Tax will remain. Here's hoping some quality free agents believe the Marlins have done enough to make that competing case. View full article
  2. Do MLB players want to play for the Miami Marlins? As another offseason gets underway, the same old question returns for fans of the league's southernmost franchise. For much of their history—certainly much of this century—the answer has been a resounding no. To be fair, it's been hard to blame them. While the game is a business first and foremost, winning and stability still count for plenty. Those are things that have seldom been on the menu for Marlins players. Throw in an empty ballpark, and it's just a tough sell for free agents. Thus, the existence of what I've come to call the Marlins Tax. The unfortunate reality where the Marlins are forced to pay well above market value for likely below average talent. In other words, Miami is doubly penalized when they turn to free agency. Have the Marlins finally graduated from needing to pay it? The answer to that question will only define their entire offseason. Fortunately for Marlins fans, there's a compelling case to be made that the answer is yes. The team has gotten better for three straight seasons, and the expectation in baseball circles is for that trend to continue in 2027. The vibes are strong in Miami under the watch of team president Peter Bendix, even if Bruce Sherman remains the owner. And even Sherman has drawn some kudos for his investment in the team''s spring training facility, as well as the organization's Dominican Academy. The Marlins have a young core and a solid farm system. There's a lot to recommend. Could it be that players now regard South Florida the same way they do St. Petersburg? A smart, savvy organization committed to winning? Unfortunately, I'm still inclined to say the answer is no. The Tax still applies. As with everything else you're going to hear this offseason, it all comes down to payroll, and the Marlins did just spend another season in the cellar moneywise. Fairly or not, the Marlins continue to be tagged for spending in a way the Rays are not, and that will continue to be the case until the Marlins have their own pile of playoff appearances to point towards. The jury is also still very much out on how players view Miami's unorthodox changes the past two seasons, namely calling pitches from the dugout and using starters as relievers on pitch design days. One man's shrewd winning strategy is another's penny pinching necessity. However, two things could flip the script for the Marlins very quickly. Firstly, extensions. A single big name extension could be enough to convince players that Miami really is serious about consistently competing. Putting some money behind their core would send a clear message to free agents that the window is open. What pitcher wouldn't want to know they could count on having Joe Mack as a battery-mate? What player wouldn't want to play alongside a teammate like Sandy Alcantara, or a talent like Eury Perez? Secondly, and this is the wild card, do players believe that salary reform is coming to MLB? If the answer is yes? Then the Marlins suddenly become much more like the Dolphins, Heat, and Panthers, able to sell sunshine and lack of income tax to entice players to come here. In which case, the Marlins Tax is gone. If the answer is no? Then Miami remains as merely possibly preferable to Pittsburgh, at least until they prove they can be counted on to compete. Until which time the Marlins Tax will remain. Here's hoping some quality free agents believe the Marlins have done enough to make that competing case.
  3. Rumor has it the Miami Marlins are in the market for veteran starting pitching. Now, if that sounds awfully familiar to anyone reading this, it should. Miami has been here before in recent offseasons. With Chris Paddack. With Cal Quantrill. With Johnny Cueto. With Wei-Yin Chen and Dan Straily. Just about every time the Marlins have tried to bet on a pitcher in free agency or trade for one with the intention of helping the team in the short term, the results have been less than wanting. You have to go back well over a decade to the likes of Javier Vazquez in 2011 and Mark Buerhle in 2012 for clear, unequivocal wins on this front. Understandably, it's only bringing in veteran talent to fill out the rotation that has been the problem. Finding and developing rookies? Not so much. Getting good arms in exchange for blowing up a roster? Chef's kisses for multiple GMs in club history. From Sandy Alcantara and Eury Perez on down, it's been a ridiculously good century of the Marlins producing young aces. It's the back of the rotation that has been the issue. Part of Miami's problem here has been too much bargain-bin shopping for the most important asset in baseball. As the old saying goes, you get what you pay for. The Marlins have undoubtedly had some sickeningly bad luck on a few of these moves, with way too much falling off a cliff and not enough gradual regression. However, I think it's also fair to say that the upside has just been severely wanting. Far too many of these moves have been strictly for innings eaters who might achieve a sub-4.00 ERA. The downside is what you just saw last year with Paddack: somebody who's no longer MLB-caliber in any role (although North America's loss is Asia's gain). Which brings us to Kris Bubic , the man who—pending a physical—the Marlins should pounce on as soon as possible. Why? Because the only thing really scary about him is health. Bubic has pitched like one of the better pitchers in baseball as recently as 2026. In 2025, he was an All-Star. He won't turn 30 until August, and for four straight seasons has been good whenever he's been on the mound. He gets strikeouts. He keeps the ball on the ground. He's stingy with the walks. In other words, this is not another Paddack or Tim Anderson signing, where you cross your fingers hoping an aging player turns it on one more time. He's good right now. Really, there's nothing not to like. Except for the fact that his arm could fall off at any moment. Granted, that's a valid concern. There's a reason he barely cracks the MLB Trade Rumors Top 50 free agents. The thing is though, the arm might not fall off. At the very least, it might stay on until Robby Snelling and Thomas White are ready. In which case, the Marlins would be getting an All-Star pitcher for a price they could easily afford. That same MLBTR prediction piece only has him projected for a one-year deal, two at the most, making slightly less money annually than they just paid Pete Fairbanks. Essentially, a prove-it deal. Sounds perfect. If it works out? The club has added a borderline ace. Again, he's been that for two seasons now, and a good reliever before that. If it doesn't? The team can at least claim to have spent some real money once again on a free agent—something that is always of value for the Marlins from a PR standpoint. Not to mention having made an aggressive, win-now move. It's a win no matter what for Miami. View full article
  4. Rumor has it the Miami Marlins are in the market for veteran starting pitching. Now, if that sounds awfully familiar to anyone reading this, it should. Miami has been here before in recent offseasons. With Chris Paddack. With Cal Quantrill. With Johnny Cueto. With Wei-Yin Chen and Dan Straily. Just about every time the Marlins have tried to bet on a pitcher in free agency or trade for one with the intention of helping the team in the short term, the results have been less than wanting. You have to go back well over a decade to the likes of Javier Vazquez in 2011 and Mark Buerhle in 2012 for clear, unequivocal wins on this front. Understandably, it's only bringing in veteran talent to fill out the rotation that has been the problem. Finding and developing rookies? Not so much. Getting good arms in exchange for blowing up a roster? Chef's kisses for multiple GMs in club history. From Sandy Alcantara and Eury Perez on down, it's been a ridiculously good century of the Marlins producing young aces. It's the back of the rotation that has been the issue. Part of Miami's problem here has been too much bargain-bin shopping for the most important asset in baseball. As the old saying goes, you get what you pay for. The Marlins have undoubtedly had some sickeningly bad luck on a few of these moves, with way too much falling off a cliff and not enough gradual regression. However, I think it's also fair to say that the upside has just been severely wanting. Far too many of these moves have been strictly for innings eaters who might achieve a sub-4.00 ERA. The downside is what you just saw last year with Paddack: somebody who's no longer MLB-caliber in any role (although North America's loss is Asia's gain). Which brings us to Kris Bubic , the man who—pending a physical—the Marlins should pounce on as soon as possible. Why? Because the only thing really scary about him is health. Bubic has pitched like one of the better pitchers in baseball as recently as 2026. In 2025, he was an All-Star. He won't turn 30 until August, and for four straight seasons has been good whenever he's been on the mound. He gets strikeouts. He keeps the ball on the ground. He's stingy with the walks. In other words, this is not another Paddack or Tim Anderson signing, where you cross your fingers hoping an aging player turns it on one more time. He's good right now. Really, there's nothing not to like. Except for the fact that his arm could fall off at any moment. Granted, that's a valid concern. There's a reason he barely cracks the MLB Trade Rumors Top 50 free agents. The thing is though, the arm might not fall off. At the very least, it might stay on until Robby Snelling and Thomas White are ready. In which case, the Marlins would be getting an All-Star pitcher for a price they could easily afford. That same MLBTR prediction piece only has him projected for a one-year deal, two at the most, making slightly less money annually than they just paid Pete Fairbanks. Essentially, a prove-it deal. Sounds perfect. If it works out? The club has added a borderline ace. Again, he's been that for two seasons now, and a good reliever before that. If it doesn't? The team can at least claim to have spent some real money once again on a free agent—something that is always of value for the Marlins from a PR standpoint. Not to mention having made an aggressive, win-now move. It's a win no matter what for Miami.
  5. Barring a miracle, it looks to be another disappointing election, Marlins fans. For that is truly what it would take. A former Marlin making it into the National Baseball Hall of Fame this winter would be surprising enough. Seeing them choose to do so in a Marlins cap? As I said, miraculous. What's that? Some of you were thinking of today's voting? Well yes, Election Day is here, but it's a much more baseball focused, wintertime election cycle we'll be focusing on. As every Miami fan knows, no player has ever gone into Cooperstown representing the Marlins. Certainly, plenty of Hall of Famers spent some time in Marlins colors. Andre Dawson and Tim Raines soaked up some sunshine at the end of their careers. Trevor Hoffman started his. Jim Leyland led Miami to a championship. Ivan Rodriguez helped them win another. Ichiro Suzuki collected his 3,000th hit. Mike Piazza spent a week becoming one of baseball's favorite trivia answers. However, none of them chose to be immortalized as a Marlin. This offseason could easily determine if anyone ever does. How so? Multiple decisions to be made between now and next Opening Day will play a role. Some of those are well within Miami's control. Others? Less so. Yet all will go a long way towards deciding whether fans can count on a Marlins Hall of Famer anytime soon. Starting with... Their Current Aces Will the Marlins offer Sandy Alcantara an extension? He's by no means a lock for Cooperstown, but he's also one of only two active Marlins you could squint and see getting there. If Sandy were to spend his entire career in South Florida being his above average innings eater self, and that career continues for another six to eight years? That could end up being recognized. Then there's Eury Perez. This winter feels like the last chance for an extension, barring a massive change to Miami's financial situation. Speaking of which... Will Baseball Get Salary Reform? Outside of Alcantara, this one is really the whole ballgame. Honestly, even that Perez mention should have been included in this section. It's just really hard to see the Marlins keeping anyone good enough long enough without the proposed salary cap and floor. If it were just about one great year, Leyland or Rodriguez would have gone in as Marlins. Same for Miguel Cabrera in a couple years. It's about the excellence and tenure, which is an expensive combination. Likely too expensive for Miami without salary reform. Unless... Will Miami's Home Run Leader Return Home? Last and least likely, what if Giancarlo Stanton finished his career in South Florida? The Yankees could easily cut him. Technically, the Marlins are already spending $10 million on him anyway. Would it be so shocking if the team sought to sell some tickets and give him the chance for an Albert Pujols ending to his career? Returning home to chase home run history? It would take him accepting a sweetheart deal, and Miami looking past the fact he's likely cooked. It would be quite the storybook ending though. Barring one of these scenarios? That could be it for Miami winning a Hall of Fame vote. View full article
  6. Barring a miracle, it looks to be another disappointing election, Marlins fans. For that is truly what it would take. A former Marlin making it into the National Baseball Hall of Fame this winter would be surprising enough. Seeing them choose to do so in a Marlins cap? As I said, miraculous. What's that? Some of you were thinking of today's voting? Well yes, Election Day is here, but it's a much more baseball focused, wintertime election cycle we'll be focusing on. As every Miami fan knows, no player has ever gone into Cooperstown representing the Marlins. Certainly, plenty of Hall of Famers spent some time in Marlins colors. Andre Dawson and Tim Raines soaked up some sunshine at the end of their careers. Trevor Hoffman started his. Jim Leyland led Miami to a championship. Ivan Rodriguez helped them win another. Ichiro Suzuki collected his 3,000th hit. Mike Piazza spent a week becoming one of baseball's favorite trivia answers. However, none of them chose to be immortalized as a Marlin. This offseason could easily determine if anyone ever does. How so? Multiple decisions to be made between now and next Opening Day will play a role. Some of those are well within Miami's control. Others? Less so. Yet all will go a long way towards deciding whether fans can count on a Marlins Hall of Famer anytime soon. Starting with... Their Current Aces Will the Marlins offer Sandy Alcantara an extension? He's by no means a lock for Cooperstown, but he's also one of only two active Marlins you could squint and see getting there. If Sandy were to spend his entire career in South Florida being his above average innings eater self, and that career continues for another six to eight years? That could end up being recognized. Then there's Eury Perez. This winter feels like the last chance for an extension, barring a massive change to Miami's financial situation. Speaking of which... Will Baseball Get Salary Reform? Outside of Alcantara, this one is really the whole ballgame. Honestly, even that Perez mention should have been included in this section. It's just really hard to see the Marlins keeping anyone good enough long enough without the proposed salary cap and floor. If it were just about one great year, Leyland or Rodriguez would have gone in as Marlins. Same for Miguel Cabrera in a couple years. It's about the excellence and tenure, which is an expensive combination. Likely too expensive for Miami without salary reform. Unless... Will Miami's Home Run Leader Return Home? Last and least likely, what if Giancarlo Stanton finished his career in South Florida? The Yankees could easily cut him. Technically, the Marlins are already spending $10 million on him anyway. Would it be so shocking if the team sought to sell some tickets and give him the chance for an Albert Pujols ending to his career? Returning home to chase home run history? It would take him accepting a sweetheart deal, and Miami looking past the fact he's likely cooked. It would be quite the storybook ending though. Barring one of these scenarios? That could be it for Miami winning a Hall of Fame vote.
  7. We're nearing five years since the last time the Miami Marlins faced the prospect of an upcoming MLB lockout. Bruce Sherman remains the owner. The Marlins' aspirations are essentially the same—have a winning record and make the playoffs. It's also anyone's guess when Miami will next play a baseball game. Other than that? Everything has changed. No more Derek Jeter. No more Kim Ng. Miami's roster is in a far better place. Perhaps more importantly, this CBA deadline brings a higher likelihood of real change to the game's financial landscape. Then again, Miami's entire approach to team building has changed dramatically since then. In short, it may well be a fool's errand to try to draw any concrete lessons for this Marlins offseason from that of 2021-22. However, Sherman is still the man cutting the checks, and his memory of how things went last time around will undoubtedly play a part. Same goes for that of other senior officials, with new president of baseball operations Peter Bendix foremost among them (he was general manager of the Tampa Bay Rays last time around). So let's start with Sherman and the headliners of that offseason, namely the best and worst decisions of his ownership era. Right before the start of the last MLB lockout, the Marlins announced two eleventh-hour moves. One of those was an extension for Sandy Alcantara, which he is about to enter the last year of now that Miami has exercised their club option. Unfortunately, the other was the signing of free agent Avisaíl García to four-year, $53 million deal that the team just finished paying off. Obviously, the outcomes of those two decisions couldn't have been more different. Before breaking down the potential lessons, I'd be remiss not to note that both of them did equally check one box the Marlins could try to check again this November: Spending. Even heading into the last CBA, the pressure was on Miami to spend more. That will arguably be even more true heading into 2027. Therefore, a big expenditure of some kind on the Marlins part shouldn't come as a surprise. But what will that look like? On the Sandy side, could Sherman be well disposed to greenlighting another club friendly extension? Either that, or doubling down on his prior investment with another Alcantara extension? Sandy has proven a sound investment, and for the first time in years, the Marlins have multiple young players with proven resumes worth a long-term commitment. Yet on the García side, it also feels safe to assume that the Marlins won't be rushing into any big free-agent deals. Other than Jorge Soler later that same offseason, no FA has received a multi-year commitment from Miami since then. The Miami Herald's Barry Jackson reported last week that the team would not sign any "marquee 30-plus free-agents to enormous deals." In short, I'd bet heavily on an extension or two, but wouldn't count on a true free-agent splurge. Trades could be a different story, though. The Marlins acquired Jacob Stallings and Joey Wendle in the month leading up to the last CBA deadline. The Wendle move could be particularly worth dwelling on, as it was one of six trades that Bendix's Tampa Bay Rays made during that span. One of those, by the way, brought in a young prospect named Junior Caminero. In my opinion, it all points to a busy month for the Marlins.
  8. We're nearing five years since the last time the Miami Marlins faced the prospect of an upcoming MLB lockout. Bruce Sherman remains the owner. The Marlins' aspirations are essentially the same—have a winning record and make the playoffs. It's also anyone's guess when Miami will next play a baseball game. Other than that? Everything has changed. No more Derek Jeter. No more Kim Ng. Miami's roster is in a far better place. Perhaps more importantly, this CBA deadline brings a higher likelihood of real change to the game's financial landscape. Then again, Miami's entire approach to team building has changed dramatically since then. In short, it may well be a fool's errand to try to draw any concrete lessons for this Marlins offseason from that of 2021-22. However, Sherman is still the man cutting the checks, and his memory of how things went last time around will undoubtedly play a part. Same goes for that of other senior officials, with new president of baseball operations Peter Bendix foremost among them (he was general manager of the Tampa Bay Rays last time around). So let's start with Sherman and the headliners of that offseason, namely the best and worst decisions of his ownership era. Right before the start of the last MLB lockout, the Marlins announced two eleventh-hour moves. One of those was an extension for Sandy Alcantara, which he is about to enter the last year of now that Miami has exercised their club option. Unfortunately, the other was the signing of free agent Avisaíl García to four-year, $53 million deal that the team just finished paying off. Obviously, the outcomes of those two decisions couldn't have been more different. Before breaking down the potential lessons, I'd be remiss not to note that both of them did equally check one box the Marlins could try to check again this November: Spending. Even heading into the last CBA, the pressure was on Miami to spend more. That will arguably be even more true heading into 2027. Therefore, a big expenditure of some kind on the Marlins part shouldn't come as a surprise. But what will that look like? On the Sandy side, could Sherman be well disposed to greenlighting another club friendly extension? Either that, or doubling down on his prior investment with another Alcantara extension? Sandy has proven a sound investment, and for the first time in years, the Marlins have multiple young players with proven resumes worth a long-term commitment. Yet on the García side, it also feels safe to assume that the Marlins won't be rushing into any big free-agent deals. Other than Jorge Soler later that same offseason, no FA has received a multi-year commitment from Miami since then. The Miami Herald's Barry Jackson reported last week that the team would not sign any "marquee 30-plus free-agents to enormous deals." In short, I'd bet heavily on an extension or two, but wouldn't count on a true free-agent splurge. Trades could be a different story, though. The Marlins acquired Jacob Stallings and Joey Wendle in the month leading up to the last CBA deadline. The Wendle move could be particularly worth dwelling on, as it was one of six trades that Bendix's Tampa Bay Rays made during that span. One of those, by the way, brought in a young prospect named Junior Caminero. In my opinion, it all points to a busy month for the Marlins. View full article
  9. When it comes to the Milwaukee Brewers and Tampa Bay Rays, there is no shortage of former Miami Marlins to choose from. Brewers captain Christian Yelich headlines that crop, and would have even before Derek Jeter reminded the baseball world he traded him to Milwaukee. On the Rays side, this series will see them prominently feature two players current Marlins president Peter Bendix traded to his former team. Retired Fish who played for either side include Gary Sheffield, Charles Johnson, Chuck Carr, Trevor Hoffman, Craig Counsell, Devon White, and Liván Hernández. Seriously, it might be easier to name a 1997 Marlin that didn't play for one of these teams. But what about former Fish who played for both Milwaukee and Tampa? That list gets far shorter. Fourteen, to be precise. Now while I freely admit a forgotten reliever could have been lost in the shuffle here, there is no debate about this crop being much less stellar than the above group. Only one Marlins World Series ring among them. Backup catcher Gregg Zaun has that honor, last alphabetically but first in terms of career WAR (13.7) among them. However, that is far from the most recognized Marlin on this list. That honor goes to the worst free-agent signing in franchise history, Avisaíl García. Much attention will be rightly given to the first player mentioned in this article during this series, and what has befallen the Brewers, Marlins, and Yelich since that fateful trade. Yet the staggering flop García proved to be has been nearly as damaging. Remember, one of Miami's largest expenses this past season was the $5 million issued to Garcia to finish off his burdensome contract. It's a fate made all the more horrifying by the fact his 9.4 career WAR ranks second on this list behind Zaun, despite a -1.9 Miami tally. Moving on, what about Jesús Aguilar and Logan Morrison? Only seven players have hit more homers for Miami in the Sherman era than Aguilar, who was a key piece of that 2020 playoff team. Older fans will fondly remember Morrison's 23-homer showing in 2011, and older millennials will even more fondly remember his social media antics. Beyond that, it's a who's who of former faces. Burke Badenhop and Brad Boxberger round out the players most fans remember hearing about. Afterwards? John Curtiss, Joe Dillon, Preston Guilmet, Alex Jackson, Dan Jennings, Trevor Richards, Gerald Williams, and Josh Wilson bring up the rear. Badenhop was part of the infamous Cabrera-Willis trade. Two years after Miami dealt Richards to Tampa, the Rays flipped him to Milwaukee for a package that included Drew Rasmussen. So as another World Series plays out without the Marlins, trust in the fact that history runs deep between these three clubs. And that no matter what happens, Miami will still have more championships than the winner when it's over. View full article
  10. When it comes to the Milwaukee Brewers and Tampa Bay Rays, there is no shortage of former Miami Marlins to choose from. Brewers captain Christian Yelich headlines that crop, and would have even before Derek Jeter reminded the baseball world he traded him to Milwaukee. On the Rays side, this series will see them prominently feature two players current Marlins president Peter Bendix traded to his former team. Retired Fish who played for either side include Gary Sheffield, Charles Johnson, Chuck Carr, Trevor Hoffman, Craig Counsell, Devon White, and Liván Hernández. Seriously, it might be easier to name a 1997 Marlin that didn't play for one of these teams. But what about former Fish who played for both Milwaukee and Tampa? That list gets far shorter. Fourteen, to be precise. Now while I freely admit a forgotten reliever could have been lost in the shuffle here, there is no debate about this crop being much less stellar than the above group. Only one Marlins World Series ring among them. Backup catcher Gregg Zaun has that honor, last alphabetically but first in terms of career WAR (13.7) among them. However, that is far from the most recognized Marlin on this list. That honor goes to the worst free-agent signing in franchise history, Avisaíl García. Much attention will be rightly given to the first player mentioned in this article during this series, and what has befallen the Brewers, Marlins, and Yelich since that fateful trade. Yet the staggering flop García proved to be has been nearly as damaging. Remember, one of Miami's largest expenses this past season was the $5 million issued to Garcia to finish off his burdensome contract. It's a fate made all the more horrifying by the fact his 9.4 career WAR ranks second on this list behind Zaun, despite a -1.9 Miami tally. Moving on, what about Jesús Aguilar and Logan Morrison? Only seven players have hit more homers for Miami in the Sherman era than Aguilar, who was a key piece of that 2020 playoff team. Older fans will fondly remember Morrison's 23-homer showing in 2011, and older millennials will even more fondly remember his social media antics. Beyond that, it's a who's who of former faces. Burke Badenhop and Brad Boxberger round out the players most fans remember hearing about. Afterwards? John Curtiss, Joe Dillon, Preston Guilmet, Alex Jackson, Dan Jennings, Trevor Richards, Gerald Williams, and Josh Wilson bring up the rear. Badenhop was part of the infamous Cabrera-Willis trade. Two years after Miami dealt Richards to Tampa, the Rays flipped him to Milwaukee for a package that included Drew Rasmussen. So as another World Series plays out without the Marlins, trust in the fact that history runs deep between these three clubs. And that no matter what happens, Miami will still have more championships than the winner when it's over.
  11. In case you haven't heard, the Miami Marlins have made some changes to their broadcasting team entering 2027. They have ignited an absolute firestorm in Marlins social media circles. In short, it's easy to see the Marlins wanting to improve their broadcasts. Based on his fine work this year, it's equally easy to see how Jack McMullen could be seen as an elite broadcasting asset that had to be kept no matter what. Unfortunately, it's also easy to understand how the Marlins remain an easy target any time they do something that could be argued—fairly or not—to involve finances. On top of that, even the most objective and seasoned journalists in this market could still be feeling pretty raw after a summer full of financially driven South Florida media firings. The main reason this off-the-field matter has commanded so much attention is that the Marlins don't win. The last time the Marlins even had consecutive winning seasons was 2008-09. They've never made the playoffs in consecutive years. If you throw out 2020, Bruce Sherman has only had one winning season in nearly a decade of ownership. Suffice it to say, DJ Khaled didn't have the Marlins in mind when he dropped All I Do Is Win. Meanwhile, the Marlins are right near the bottom of MLB in terms of payroll, just like the Guardians and Rays. Even the Brewers are being outspent by most other teams. Yet all three are still playing in October. Cleveland and Milwaukee have had more winning seasons in the past decade than Miami has had in their entire history. Tampa is one short of tying that mark. Would those clubs would receive this much flack if they culled their broadcasting crews? Zero chance. Higher spending even without winning results would save the Marlins a lot of the fire they receive, and the timing of the news also worked to their detriment. Had it come deeper in the offseason following roster improvements or extensions for core players, it'd be a less prominent story. Let this be a reminder that the baseball operations department is but one branch of a major league organization. It's clear to everyone that things are getting better in Miami. The Marlins outscored their opponents in 2026 for the first time in 16 years, practically all of their veteran talent is under club control for next season and more standout prospects are on the cusp of debuting. Yet until that starts resulting in consistent winning, playoff-caliber seasons? They will continue not to get the benefit of the doubt. Winning is the cure-all for this team, far more than any broadcasting or spending change. The sooner that happens, the better.
  12. In case you haven't heard, the Miami Marlins have made some changes to their broadcasting team entering 2027. They have ignited an absolute firestorm in Marlins social media circles. In short, it's easy to see the Marlins wanting to improve their broadcasts. Based on his fine work this year, it's equally easy to see how Jack McMullen could be seen as an elite broadcasting asset that had to be kept no matter what. Unfortunately, it's also easy to understand how the Marlins remain an easy target any time they do something that could be argued—fairly or not—to involve finances. On top of that, even the most objective and seasoned journalists in this market could still be feeling pretty raw after a summer full of financially driven South Florida media firings. The main reason this off-the-field matter has commanded so much attention is that the Marlins don't win. The last time the Marlins even had consecutive winning seasons was 2008-09. They've never made the playoffs in consecutive years. If you throw out 2020, Bruce Sherman has only had one winning season in nearly a decade of ownership. Suffice it to say, DJ Khaled didn't have the Marlins in mind when he dropped All I Do Is Win. Meanwhile, the Marlins are right near the bottom of MLB in terms of payroll, just like the Guardians and Rays. Even the Brewers are being outspent by most other teams. Yet all three are still playing in October. Cleveland and Milwaukee have had more winning seasons in the past decade than Miami has had in their entire history. Tampa is one short of tying that mark. Would those clubs would receive this much flack if they culled their broadcasting crews? Zero chance. Higher spending even without winning results would save the Marlins a lot of the fire they receive, and the timing of the news also worked to their detriment. Had it come deeper in the offseason following roster improvements or extensions for core players, it'd be a less prominent story. Let this be a reminder that the baseball operations department is but one branch of a major league organization. It's clear to everyone that things are getting better in Miami. The Marlins outscored their opponents in 2026 for the first time in 16 years, practically all of their veteran talent is under club control for next season and more standout prospects are on the cusp of debuting. Yet until that starts resulting in consistent winning, playoff-caliber seasons? They will continue not to get the benefit of the doubt. Winning is the cure-all for this team, far more than any broadcasting or spending change. The sooner that happens, the better. View full article
  13. It's certainly been a wild few months for South Florida sports. Unremarkable on the field—the Heat, Marlins, and Panthers all missed the playoffs, while the Dolphins spent the summer projected to make a real run at going 0-17. However, there has been borderline cataclysmic change to the way sports is covered in this market. The Miami Herald was gutted in recent weeks, with Greg Cote and Michelle Kauffman headlining the layoffs. Three months prior, the Sun Sentinel fired Dave Hyde. Voices that shaped the way sports were understood in Miami for decades abruptly cast aside. It's been tough, and every writer let go this summer deserved better. At the same time all of this is going on, a Miami Marlins legend has also called it a career. Fortunately, he has gotten the opportunity to do so entirely on his own terms, featuring a full-season retirement tour and special pregame ceremony at loanDepot park. I'm speaking, of course, of Tommy Hutton. Aside from what we'll call the Wilderness Period of 2016 through early 2018, Hutton was a part of the Marlins broadcast crew since 1997. If you care about this team, follow them on any kind of a regular basis, then it's a safe bet that the way you know and love the game of baseball was shaped by his insight and passion. Back when the news first broke that this season would be Hutton's swan song, I made the case on another platform for him needing to be a lock for the 2027 Marlins Hall of Fame class. Suffice it to say, you can expect a refresh of that for this site this spring. Historically, it has been rare for anyone associated with this franchise to get a storybook ending to their tenure. Hutton's longtime broadcast partner Rich Waltz didn't get it, at least not until Sunday when the team helped facilitate his return to the booth for one last inning with Tommy. That emotional reunion coincided with a Griffin Conine home run; the moment would have only been more perfect for Marlins fans if the two had taken a moment to let us know his name wasn't DAN UGGLA. Sunday afternoon went a long way towards righting last decade's wrong of splitting up Waltz and Hutton. Everyone involved deserves a ton of credit for that. It was just great seeing a man so involved with so much of this team's history go out because he chose to do so at 80 years young, rather than having that choice forced on him. It was a moment that meant a lot on the Marlins fan front and quite a bit just in terms of the local sports coverage front as well. Congrats, Tommy, and thank you. View full article
  14. It's certainly been a wild few months for South Florida sports. Unremarkable on the field—the Heat, Marlins, and Panthers all missed the playoffs, while the Dolphins spent the summer projected to make a real run at going 0-17. However, there has been borderline cataclysmic change to the way sports is covered in this market. The Miami Herald was gutted in recent weeks, with Greg Cote and Michelle Kauffman headlining the layoffs. Three months prior, the Sun Sentinel fired Dave Hyde. Voices that shaped the way sports were understood in Miami for decades abruptly cast aside. It's been tough, and every writer let go this summer deserved better. At the same time all of this is going on, a Miami Marlins legend has also called it a career. Fortunately, he has gotten the opportunity to do so entirely on his own terms, featuring a full-season retirement tour and special pregame ceremony at loanDepot park. I'm speaking, of course, of Tommy Hutton. Aside from what we'll call the Wilderness Period of 2016 through early 2018, Hutton was a part of the Marlins broadcast crew since 1997. If you care about this team, follow them on any kind of a regular basis, then it's a safe bet that the way you know and love the game of baseball was shaped by his insight and passion. Back when the news first broke that this season would be Hutton's swan song, I made the case on another platform for him needing to be a lock for the 2027 Marlins Hall of Fame class. Suffice it to say, you can expect a refresh of that for this site this spring. Historically, it has been rare for anyone associated with this franchise to get a storybook ending to their tenure. Hutton's longtime broadcast partner Rich Waltz didn't get it, at least not until Sunday when the team helped facilitate his return to the booth for one last inning with Tommy. That emotional reunion coincided with a Griffin Conine home run; the moment would have only been more perfect for Marlins fans if the two had taken a moment to let us know his name wasn't DAN UGGLA. Sunday afternoon went a long way towards righting last decade's wrong of splitting up Waltz and Hutton. Everyone involved deserves a ton of credit for that. It was just great seeing a man so involved with so much of this team's history go out because he chose to do so at 80 years young, rather than having that choice forced on him. It was a moment that meant a lot on the Marlins fan front and quite a bit just in terms of the local sports coverage front as well. Congrats, Tommy, and thank you.
  15. Was there anything the Miami Marlins could have realistically done this summer to make them a contender this October? Probably not. Not after giving up every inch of ground they gained thanks to that franchise worst twelve-game losing streak. Not after the San Diego Padres remembered they had one of the most talented rosters in baseball. Not after former Marlins manager Don Mattingly reminded the Philadelphia Phillies of the same thing. And yet...it's hard to shake the sense that the Marlins could have done more at the trade deadline. That they left opportunities on the table. In short, that they completely punted on the chance to make the playoffs for the third time in the Bruce Sherman era. Would they have been a long shot to do so? Absolutely. Would it have been a breath of fresh air for the team to make the attempt? You bet. Keeping the band together was enough in 2025. However, this 2026 club flashed more talent while also being in more dire need of a boost. Especially when you factor in how unstoppable Sandy Alcantara and Eury Perez were looking at the time and the tantalizing prospect of putting them in a playoff series. Twelve-game losing streak or not, this really seemed like a squad that had earned more faith than the front office demonstrated in it come deadline time. Unfortunately, there's also no denying what a mistake it would have been to really push the chips in. This team wasn't ready, and the primary reason for that was lack of depth. When depth is your biggest issue, at least until baseball gets that salary cap, teams like Miami can't go crazy selling off young talent for rental pieces. Plus, once Tariq Skubal went, it's not as if there were a ton of available options worth the price tag. The Marlins weren't even one piece away from a title when they were firing on all cylinders, and were in far worse shape when August arrived. Being responsible made sense, and if we're all being honest with ourselves, it isn't exactly hard to see the wisdom in the uber-frugal approach Miami ultimately took. Which is all fine. Pragmatic, savvy, smart stuff from the Marlins front office, which continues to be a breath of fresh air in its own right. On one condition though: That that same smart front office do everything they can to build on this foundation in 2027. Sign free agents, and good ones. No dealing multiple pieces away from the MLB roster for pieces that might help three years from now. Spend the money on the field that wasn't spent there last winter. Past years have seen the Marlins fill holes by creating new ones, and just betting the ranch on the 90% outcome happening. That has to change. For again, the big issue this season was depth. After a few months of covering that up with smoke and mirrors, the Marlins ran out of bodies and gas. Of course, at a couple positions, the tricks never worked at all. Far too much time was given to Christopher Morel and Leo Jimenez to make it work. Far too often when Miami played platoon games and pulled pitchers down the stretch, they did so with players that simply weren't capable of consistently delivering the desired outcome. Those moves are clearly going to be part of how the Marlins operate, and that too is fine, pragmatic, savvy, smart stuff. Yet the talent level of Miami's bench and bullpen must be much higher next time around to make that work, and the easiest way to do that is to inject talent into the MLB roster without needing to take talent away from it. Basically, for three offseasons in a row, the Marlins have made it too easy for fans to argue that the team made the big league roster worse during the offseason, not better. That can't happen again, not now that there are real expectations associated with this group. Otherwise, the Marlins just wasted a chance for a month of much more meaningful baseball, and all the goodwill and memories that come with that. View full article
×
×
  • Create New...