-
Posts
3,587 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
269
Content Type
Profiles
Miami Marlins Videos
2026 Miami Marlins Top Prospects Ranking
Miami Marlins Free Agent & Trade Rumors, Notes, & Tidbits
Guides & Resources
2025 Miami Marlins Draft Picks
News
2025 Miami Marlins Draft Pick Tracker
Forums
Blogs
Events
Store
Downloads
Gallery
Everything posted by Ely Sussman
-
Eury Pérez to have Tommy John surgery, miss rest of 2024 season
Ely Sussman posted an article in Marlins
Eury Pérez's sophomore season is over before it even began. Miami Marlins president of baseball operations Peter Bendix announced on Thursday that the ascending star right-hander will undergo Tommy John surgery. Pérez had been on the injured list after experiencing elbow inflammation during spring training. Surgery was not recommended initially and he was cleared to restart a throwing progression. The 20-year-old had advanced to throwing bullpen sessions, but Craig Mish of SportsGrid reports that he felt elbow tightness on Tuesday and noticed a drop in velocity. Dr. Keith Meister will perform the procedure on Pérez. He's the same doctor who operated on Pérez's mentor, Sandy Alcantara. Starting pitchers typically need more than 12 months to return to competition following Tommy John, with younger starters being handled especially carefully. Pérez will not be ready by Opening Day 2025, complicating the Marlins' plans for next season. He will continue to accrue MLB service time throughout the rehab process (he had 113 days of service entering 2024). In the meantime, their current campaign continues to be an abject disaster. The Marlins are 0-7 entering Thursday's game against the St. Louis Cardinals. FanGraphs estimates their playoff odds at 9.9% and that will only plummet further following the news of Pérez's extended absence. The Marlins opened the regular season with a starting rotation of Jesús Luzardo, A.J. Puk, Ryan Weathers, Trevor Rogers and Max Meyer. Reinforcements are on the way in the form of Edward Cabrera and Braxton Garrett, both of whom are scheduled to make four-inning rehab starts with Triple-A Jacksonville this weekend. Pérez was promptly transferred from the 15-day IL to the 60-day IL later on Thursday afternoon to create room on the 40-man roster for waiver claim UTIL Otto López. -
Game Thread: Marlins at Cardinals, 4/4 @ 4:15 pm ET
Ely Sussman posted a topic in Miami Marlins Talk
Welcome to FOF's eighth Miami Marlins game thread of the 2024 season. The game itself understandably takes a backseat to the news that Eury Pérez is getting Tommy John surgery. SuperSubs can access exclusive game notes here. Pregame roster moves: INF Emmanuel Rivera activated, RHP Matt Andriese selected from Triple-A Jacksonville and UTIL Otto López claimed off waivers from the Giants; RHP Eury Pérez transferred to 60-day injured list, INF Jonah Bride optioned to Jacksonville and LHP Kent Emanuel designated for assignment. Nate Karzmer will be writing the game recap. -
Marlins vs. Cardinals series preview & predictions
Ely Sussman replied to Fish On First Staff's topic in Miami Marlins Talk
Hasn't had an off-day yet to catch his breath, to be fair. If this group can't put up a decent effort vs. Lance Lynn today, I would expect some tweaks. -
Player status updates, insightful stats and more information to fully equip you for today's Marlins game. Here are the latest Miami Marlins game notes, produced by the Marlins communications department and relayed to our loyal SuperSubs. Got thoughts about this matchup? Head over to Fish On First's Marlins game thread. View full article
-
-
A catastrophic blow to the Marlins' dwindling chances of being competitive this year. The surgery is expected to delay Pérez's start to the 2025 season as well. Eury Pérez's sophomore season is over before it even began. Miami Marlins president of baseball operations Peter Bendix announced on Thursday that the ascending star right-hander will undergo Tommy John surgery. Pérez had been on the injured list after experiencing elbow inflammation during spring training. Surgery was not recommended initially and he was cleared to restart a throwing progression. The 20-year-old had advanced to throwing bullpen sessions, but Craig Mish of SportsGrid reports that he felt elbow tightness on Tuesday and noticed a drop in velocity. Dr. Keith Meister will perform the procedure on Pérez. He's the same doctor who operated on Pérez's mentor, Sandy Alcantara. Starting pitchers typically need more than 12 months to return to competition following Tommy John, with younger starters being handled especially carefully. Pérez will not be ready by Opening Day 2025, complicating the Marlins' plans for next season. He will continue to accrue MLB service time throughout the rehab process (he had 113 days of service entering 2024). In the meantime, their current campaign continues to be an abject disaster. The Marlins are 0-7 entering Thursday's game against the St. Louis Cardinals. FanGraphs estimates their playoff odds at 9.9% and that will only plummet further following the news of Pérez's extended absence. The Marlins opened the regular season with a starting rotation of Jesús Luzardo, A.J. Puk, Ryan Weathers, Trevor Rogers and Max Meyer. Reinforcements are on the way in the form of Edward Cabrera and Braxton Garrett, both of whom are scheduled to make four-inning rehab starts with Triple-A Jacksonville this weekend. Pérez was promptly transferred from the 15-day IL to the 60-day IL later on Thursday afternoon to create room on the 40-man roster for waiver claim UTIL Otto López. View full article
-
Marlins vs. Cardinals series preview & predictions
Ely Sussman replied to Fish On First Staff's topic in Miami Marlins Talk
Bleday began last season on a heater as well. Let's see if it keeps up. I was okay with dealing him because Burdick looked to be the more multi-dimensional player. The Marlins didn't see it that way unfortunately and lost Burdick for nothing (he's red-hot at Triple-A, by the way). -
Marlins news roundup for 4/4/24 Player spotlight selection: Luis Arraez On Wednesday, Avisaíl García had the Marlins' lone extra-base hit. A.J. Puk improved from his previous start, but was still unremarkable (4.0 IP, 5 H, 4 R, 2 ER, 3 BB, 5 K). In relief of Puk, Burch Smith and Kent Emanuel allowed the game to get out of hand. Nolan Schanuel extended his on-base streak to 35 consecutive games, which is now the longest active streak in Major League Baseball. The Marlins lost, 10-2, for their most lopsided game result of the season thus far, finishing off a winless seven-game homestand. Down on the farm, Triple-A Jacksonville lost, 6-4. Tristan Gray and Will Banfield each homered for the second night in a row (Banfield's blast was estimated at 436 feet). Jonathan Davis stole his fourth base, one shy of the International League lead. Griffin Conine recorded the hardest-hit ball of the game at 112.2 mph. Here's more Marlins news and content for you: 🔷 We need to get into the sobering stats about this 0-7 stumble out of the starting gate. The Marlins are the first postseason team in MLB history to kick off the following season with such a lengthy losing streak. They are the 10th team in the Wild Card era to lose seven or more games in a row to begin their campaign—none of the others came remotely close to a winning record at season's end (the best of the bunch finished at 74-88). Miami's minus-27 run differential is only the third-worst in the majors, but considering they were the home team for all of these games and got to face relatively soft competition, that is not much of a silver lining. 🔷 Ken Rosenthal and Dennis Lin of The Athletic report that the Padres attempted to trade for Luis Arraez during spring training and also coveted Jesús Luzardo. "The Marlins, with the start of the season approaching, feared they could not adequately replace Arraez" (well yeah, duh). The report just states the obvious: if the Marlins continue to be one of MLB's least-competitive teams, they will have a lot of pieces to potentially sell this summer, and Peter Bendix will not shy away from those painful but necessary moves. 🔷 Glenn Geffner's View from the Bleachers reminds us that things could be much, much worse, retelling the story of the 1988 Baltimore Orioles. 🔷 Watch the full replay of Fish On First LIVE. SuperSubs still have time to submit predictions for the Marlins vs. Cardinals series. FOF LIVE is presented by Berger & Hicks. If you’ve been injured as a result of somebody else’s negligence, give them a call at (305) 670-7050. 🔷 Jacob Amaya and Vladimir Gutierrez remain in DFA limbo. 🔷 My daily player spotlight is dedicated to Arraez, who's slashing just .185/.333/.222 with a 67 wRC+ this season. He had a two-strikeout game on Wednesday (had only two of those in 2023). Even when making contact, the quality of his has been far below his usual standards—Arraez's 13.6% hard-hit rate is half of his career average. The Marlins need him to snap out of it. 🔷 Elsewhere around baseball, Shohei Ohtani hit his first home run as a Dodger. After tossing a no-hitter against them on Monday, the Astros limited the Blue Jays to only one hit in their series finale. The Tigers (4-0) are MLB's last remaining undefeated team, though they will be hard-pressed to keep that going with a doubleheader coming up today at Citi Field. 🔷 Today's game: the Marlins (probable starter LHP Ryan Weathers) visit the Cardinals (RHP Lance Lynn) at 4:15 p.m. ET. The Marlins have a 42.4% chance to win, per FanGraphs. Several roster moves are expected prior to first pitch, including the activation of recently acquired infielder Emmanuel Rivera. Marlins podcast episodes View full article
-
Offishial News: Padres made 'strong offer' to Marlins for Luis Arraez
Ely Sussman posted an article in Marlins
On Wednesday, Avisaíl García had the Marlins' lone extra-base hit. A.J. Puk improved from his previous start, but was still unremarkable (4.0 IP, 5 H, 4 R, 2 ER, 3 BB, 5 K). In relief of Puk, Burch Smith and Kent Emanuel allowed the game to get out of hand. Nolan Schanuel extended his on-base streak to 35 consecutive games, which is now the longest active streak in Major League Baseball. The Marlins lost, 10-2, for their most lopsided game result of the season thus far, finishing off a winless seven-game homestand. Down on the farm, Triple-A Jacksonville lost, 6-4. Tristan Gray and Will Banfield each homered for the second night in a row (Banfield's blast was estimated at 436 feet). Jonathan Davis stole his fourth base, one shy of the International League lead. Griffin Conine recorded the hardest-hit ball of the game at 112.2 mph. Here's more Marlins news and content for you: 🔷 We need to get into the sobering stats about this 0-7 stumble out of the starting gate. The Marlins are the first postseason team in MLB history to kick off the following season with such a lengthy losing streak. They are the 10th team in the Wild Card era to lose seven or more games in a row to begin their campaign—none of the others came remotely close to a winning record at season's end (the best of the bunch finished at 74-88). Miami's minus-27 run differential is only the third-worst in the majors, but considering they were the home team for all of these games and got to face relatively soft competition, that is not much of a silver lining. 🔷 Ken Rosenthal and Dennis Lin of The Athletic report that the Padres attempted to trade for Luis Arraez during spring training and also coveted Jesús Luzardo. "The Marlins, with the start of the season approaching, feared they could not adequately replace Arraez" (well yeah, duh). The report just states the obvious: if the Marlins continue to be one of MLB's least-competitive teams, they will have a lot of pieces to potentially sell this summer, and Peter Bendix will not shy away from those painful but necessary moves. 🔷 Glenn Geffner's View from the Bleachers reminds us that things could be much, much worse, retelling the story of the 1988 Baltimore Orioles. 🔷 Watch the full replay of Fish On First LIVE. SuperSubs still have time to submit predictions for the Marlins vs. Cardinals series. FOF LIVE is presented by Berger & Hicks. If you’ve been injured as a result of somebody else’s negligence, give them a call at (305) 670-7050. 🔷 Jacob Amaya and Vladimir Gutierrez remain in DFA limbo. 🔷 My daily player spotlight is dedicated to Arraez, who's slashing just .185/.333/.222 with a 67 wRC+ this season. He had a two-strikeout game on Wednesday (had only two of those in 2023). Even when making contact, the quality of his has been far below his usual standards—Arraez's 13.6% hard-hit rate is half of his career average. The Marlins need him to snap out of it. 🔷 Elsewhere around baseball, Shohei Ohtani hit his first home run as a Dodger. After tossing a no-hitter against them on Monday, the Astros limited the Blue Jays to only one hit in their series finale. The Tigers (4-0) are MLB's last remaining undefeated team, though they will be hard-pressed to keep that going with a doubleheader coming up today at Citi Field. 🔷 Today's game: the Marlins (probable starter LHP Ryan Weathers) visit the Cardinals (RHP Lance Lynn) at 4:15 p.m. ET. The Marlins have a 42.4% chance to win, per FanGraphs. Several roster moves are expected prior to first pitch, including the activation of recently acquired infielder Emmanuel Rivera. Marlins podcast episodes -
Player status updates, insightful stats and more information to fully equip you for today's Marlins game. Here are the latest Miami Marlins game notes, produced by the Marlins communications department and relayed to our loyal SuperSubs. Got thoughts about this matchup? Head over to Fish On First's Marlins game thread. View full article
-
-
Game Thread: Marlins vs. Angels, 4/3 @ 1:10 pm ET
Ely Sussman replied to Ely Sussman's topic in Miami Marlins Talk
-
Welcome to FOF's seventh Miami Marlins game thread of the 2024 season. It's getaway day for both teams as the Marlins seek to conclude a nightmarish homestand on a positive note. Over/under 86.5 pitches thrown by A.J. Puk? SuperSubs can access exclusive game notes here. Pregame roster moves: none (Emmanuel Rivera expected to join the team on Thursday). Enjoy live on-site coverage via Noah Berger and Daniel Rodriguez.
-
How Emmanuel Rivera can help the Marlins in 2024
Ely Sussman replied to Louis Addeo-Weiss's topic in Miami Marlins Talk
I still think this a premature concession on Amaya. Perhaps by midseason, he'd be an appropriate DFA candidate *IF* his bat took a noticeable step back. Frankly, I don't know if he's even a downgrade from Tim Anderson. The timing of this doesn't add up to me unless they're confident in arranging a trade for younger, more projectable talent. -
Marlins vs. Cardinals series preview & predictions
Ely Sussman replied to Fish On First Staff's topic in Miami Marlins Talk
Earlier than usual stream! Awkward scheduling with the Cardinals holding their home opener in the afternoon. Prediction Time submissions are welcome anytime before first pitch (4:15 p.m. ET on Thursday). -
Marlins news roundup for 4/3/24 Player spotlight selection: Bryan Hoeing On Tuesday, Tyler Anderson flummoxed the Marlins lineup, working seven scoreless, efficient innings. Jesús Luzardo faired well except when facing Aaron Hicks, whose solo home run gave the Angels an early lead that they held the rest of the night. The Marlins lost, 3-1. As Glenn Geffner points out, they're in danger of joining the 1988 Braves as the only teams in MLB's modern era to open a season with a winless homestand of seven or more games. Down on the farm, Tristan Gray and Will Banfield (AAA) hit their first homers of the season and Anthony Maldonado sealed a 5-3 win for Jacksonville with two scoreless innings of relief. Double-A Pensacola's exhibition game against Sultanes de Monterrey of the Mexican League ended in a 1-1 tie. Here's more Marlins news and content for you: 🔷 Transactions: The Marlins traded cash considerations to the Diamondbacks for Emmanuel Rivera. Rivera is expected to meet the team in St. Louis and handle a lot of the duties that were originally supposed to belong to Jon Berti. Think of Rivera as a slower version of Berti with two extra years of club control. Prospect Jacob Amaya was designated for assignment in a corresponding move. Amaya joins Vladimir Gutierrez in DFA limbo. 🔷 Read more from Louis Addeo-Weiss about Rivera's fit with his new team and from me about the bizarre sell-low approach they're taking with Amaya. 🔷 Zach Neto has made his presence felt during the ongoing series against the Angels. The Miami native plays with "a little edge" when back in his hometown, he tells Kevin Barral. 🔷 Barry Jackson of the Miami Herald is already looking ahead to the tough decisions that the Marlins could face at the trade deadline. 🔷 Recently recalled Kent Emanuel was once the poster child for college baseball's pitcher overuse problem, explains Michael Baumann of FanGraphs. 🔷 My daily player spotlight is dedicated to Bryan Hoeing. He's made two great long relief appearances so far this season. After yielding a .980 OPS to left-handed batters in 2023, he has retired all seven that he's faced in 2024. For better or worse, I'll spotlight a different Marlins player in each Offishial News article moving forward. 🔷 Elsewhere around baseball, old friend Garrett Cooper was a single shy of the cycle for the Cubs and even played left field in the final innings of a blowout win. Another old friend, Jorge Soler, mashed his first home run as a member of the Giants. Entering Tuesday without any hits this season, Bryce Harper homered three times against the Reds. Through his first two starts in 2024, Shane Bieber still hasn't allowed a run, striking out 20 batters while only walking one. 🔷 Today's game: the Marlins (probable starter LHP A.J. Puk) host the Angels (LHP Patrick Sandoval) at 1:10 p.m. ET. The Marlins have a 53.7% chance to win the series finale, per FanGraphs. Then again, their model has favored them in each of the last six games as well and gone 0-for-6. 🔷 Unconventional Fish On First LIVE schedule for us this week due to afternoon series openers. Our Cardinals series preview show will be streaming tonight at 7:00 p.m. ET on YouTube/Twitter/Facebook. FOF LIVE is presented by Berger & Hicks. If you’ve been injured as a result of somebody else’s negligence, give them a call at (305) 670-7050. Marlins podcast episodes View full article
-
- emmanuel rivera
- jacob amaya
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Offishial News: Emmanuel Rivera trade reaction; more losing streak stats
Ely Sussman posted an article in Marlins
On Tuesday, Tyler Anderson flummoxed the Marlins lineup, working seven scoreless, efficient innings. Jesús Luzardo faired well except when facing Aaron Hicks, whose solo home run gave the Angels an early lead that they held the rest of the night. The Marlins lost, 3-1. As Glenn Geffner points out, they're in danger of joining the 1988 Braves as the only teams in MLB's modern era to open a season with a winless homestand of seven or more games. Down on the farm, Tristan Gray and Will Banfield (AAA) hit their first homers of the season and Anthony Maldonado sealed a 5-3 win for Jacksonville with two scoreless innings of relief. Double-A Pensacola's exhibition game against Sultanes de Monterrey of the Mexican League ended in a 1-1 tie. Here's more Marlins news and content for you: 🔷 Transactions: The Marlins traded cash considerations to the Diamondbacks for Emmanuel Rivera. Rivera is expected to meet the team in St. Louis and handle a lot of the duties that were originally supposed to belong to Jon Berti. Think of Rivera as a slower version of Berti with two extra years of club control. Prospect Jacob Amaya was designated for assignment in a corresponding move. Amaya joins Vladimir Gutierrez in DFA limbo. 🔷 Read more from Louis Addeo-Weiss about Rivera's fit with his new team and from me about the bizarre sell-low approach they're taking with Amaya. 🔷 Zach Neto has made his presence felt during the ongoing series against the Angels. The Miami native plays with "a little edge" when back in his hometown, he tells Kevin Barral. 🔷 Barry Jackson of the Miami Herald is already looking ahead to the tough decisions that the Marlins could face at the trade deadline. 🔷 Recently recalled Kent Emanuel was once the poster child for college baseball's pitcher overuse problem, explains Michael Baumann of FanGraphs. 🔷 My daily player spotlight is dedicated to Bryan Hoeing. He's made two great long relief appearances so far this season. After yielding a .980 OPS to left-handed batters in 2023, he has retired all seven that he's faced in 2024. For better or worse, I'll spotlight a different Marlins player in each Offishial News article moving forward. 🔷 Elsewhere around baseball, old friend Garrett Cooper was a single shy of the cycle for the Cubs and even played left field in the final innings of a blowout win. Another old friend, Jorge Soler, mashed his first home run as a member of the Giants. Entering Tuesday without any hits this season, Bryce Harper homered three times against the Reds. Through his first two starts in 2024, Shane Bieber still hasn't allowed a run, striking out 20 batters while only walking one. 🔷 Today's game: the Marlins (probable starter LHP A.J. Puk) host the Angels (LHP Patrick Sandoval) at 1:10 p.m. ET. The Marlins have a 53.7% chance to win the series finale, per FanGraphs. Then again, their model has favored them in each of the last six games as well and gone 0-for-6. 🔷 Unconventional Fish On First LIVE schedule for us this week due to afternoon series openers. Our Cardinals series preview show will be streaming tonight at 7:00 p.m. ET on YouTube/Twitter/Facebook. FOF LIVE is presented by Berger & Hicks. If you’ve been injured as a result of somebody else’s negligence, give them a call at (305) 670-7050. Marlins podcast episodes-
- emmanuel rivera
- jacob amaya
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Welcome to FOF's sixth Miami Marlins game thread of the 2024 season. The roof is open at LoanDepot Park for the fifth straight game. Running a bit tardy today because the Marlins swooped in to add Emmanuel Rivera from the Arizona Diamondbacks. He'll be going on their active roster, though not in time for this contest. SuperSubs can access exclusive game notes here. Pregame roster moves: INF Emmanuel Rivera acquired from Arizona Diamondbacks in exchange for cash considerations; INF Jacob Amaya designated for assignment. Enjoy live on-site coverage via Noah Berger and Kevin Barral.
-
Player status updates, insightful stats and more information to fully equip you for today's Marlins game. Here are the latest Miami Marlins game notes, produced by the Marlins communications department and relayed to our loyal SuperSubs. Got thoughts about this matchup? Head over to Fish On First's Marlins game thread. View full article
-
-
Watch new Marlins infielder Emmanuel Rivera show off the leather at third base from his time with the Arizona Diamondbacks and Kansas City Royals. View full video
-
Watch new Marlins infielder Emmanuel Rivera show off the leather at third base from his time with the Arizona Diamondbacks and Kansas City Royals.
-
Amaya has been squeezed off Miami's 40-man roster to make room for new infielder Emmanuel Rivera. Is his value really that low? In a depleted Miami Marlins farm system, Jacob Amaya stood out for his solid shortstop defense and well-rounded plate approach...and the Marlins could potentially lose him for nothing? They surprisingly designated Amaya for assignment on Tuesday as the corresponding 40-man roster move for Emmanuel Rivera, who has been acquired from the Arizona Diamondbacks. Quite frankly, I don't get it. Fish On First was higher than most outlets on Amaya entering the 2024 season, ranking him as our No. 7 Marlins prospect. Not by much, though: MLB Pipeline ranked him ninth and Baseball America ranked him 11th. Conceding that Yiddi Cappe is destined to move off of shortstop, Amaya was seemingly the top internal option that the Marlins had at the position. In 2023, his first season in the Marlins organization, Amaya played 128 games for Triple-A Jacksonville, slashing .252/.345/.407 (89 wRC+) with 15 home runs and six stolen bases. That included 117 starts at shortstop. b25Ld1FfV0ZRVkV3dEdEUT09X1VsVURBVjBHVWdjQURsb0FCQUFBQmdSZUFBQldCbFlBQlZ3R1ZRUUFWQUJXQ0FGZg==.mp4 Amaya earned his first MLB call-up in June, though stuck around for only four games. The Marlins entrusted the shortstop position to veterans instead (Joey Wendle, Jon Berti and Garrett Hampson). After being optioned, he OPS'd just .700, which translates to a mediocre 81 wRC+ in the offensively charged International League. Fast-forward to this spring, Amaya did not get substantial reps in Grapefruit League play and was optioned back to Jacksonville two weeks in advance of Opening Day. When the Marlins traded Berti on March 27, Jonah Bride was recalled to take his spot over Amaya. Amaya has his warts, including below-average athleticism which hinders his batted ball quality and baserunning value. In the minors, his production has been underwhelming against right-handed pitching. It was difficult to envision him as a true everyday starter in the majors. Even so, Baseball Trade Values estimated that he had $6.7M in median surplus value, far above what we typically see for a DFA'd player (and far above several other Marlins 40-man players). Clearly, the Marlins did not value him as highly internally. Current Marlins shortstop Tim Anderson is only signed through this season and it's still premature to say that he'll rebound from his abysmal 2023 campaign. Berti has been dealt and slick-fielding Nasim Nuñez, who wasn't protected from the Rule 5 Draft, remains with the Washington Nationals. What is the team's plan moving forward to address this crucial position? Why the rush to DFA Amaya at this early stage of the season? In the short term, Tristan Gray and José Devers should get most of the shortstop reps for the Jumbo Shrimp. I'll wait to see where Amaya lands and what the Marlins get in return for him before rushing the judgement, but this looks on the surface like an unforced sell-low situation. View full article
-
Marlins designate top shortstop prospect Jacob Amaya for assignment
Ely Sussman posted an article in FOF Prospects
In a depleted Miami Marlins farm system, Jacob Amaya stood out for his solid shortstop defense and well-rounded plate approach...and the Marlins could potentially lose him for nothing? They surprisingly designated Amaya for assignment on Tuesday as the corresponding 40-man roster move for Emmanuel Rivera, who has been acquired from the Arizona Diamondbacks. Quite frankly, I don't get it. Fish On First was higher than most outlets on Amaya entering the 2024 season, ranking him as our No. 7 Marlins prospect. Not by much, though: MLB Pipeline ranked him ninth and Baseball America ranked him 11th. Conceding that Yiddi Cappe is destined to move off of shortstop, Amaya was seemingly the top internal option that the Marlins had at the position. In 2023, his first season in the Marlins organization, Amaya played 128 games for Triple-A Jacksonville, slashing .252/.345/.407 (89 wRC+) with 15 home runs and six stolen bases. That included 117 starts at shortstop. b25Ld1FfV0ZRVkV3dEdEUT09X1VsVURBVjBHVWdjQURsb0FCQUFBQmdSZUFBQldCbFlBQlZ3R1ZRUUFWQUJXQ0FGZg==.mp4 Amaya earned his first MLB call-up in June, though stuck around for only four games. The Marlins entrusted the shortstop position to veterans instead (Joey Wendle, Jon Berti and Garrett Hampson). After being optioned, he OPS'd just .700, which translates to a mediocre 81 wRC+ in the offensively charged International League. Fast-forward to this spring, Amaya did not get substantial reps in Grapefruit League play and was optioned back to Jacksonville two weeks in advance of Opening Day. When the Marlins traded Berti on March 27, Jonah Bride was recalled to take his spot over Amaya. Amaya has his warts, including below-average athleticism which hinders his batted ball quality and baserunning value. In the minors, his production has been underwhelming against right-handed pitching. It was difficult to envision him as a true everyday starter in the majors. Even so, Baseball Trade Values estimated that he had $6.7M in median surplus value, far above what we typically see for a DFA'd player (and far above several other Marlins 40-man players). Clearly, the Marlins did not value him as highly internally. Current Marlins shortstop Tim Anderson is only signed through this season and it's still premature to say that he'll rebound from his abysmal 2023 campaign. Berti has been dealt and slick-fielding Nasim Nuñez, who wasn't protected from the Rule 5 Draft, remains with the Washington Nationals. What is the team's plan moving forward to address this crucial position? Why the rush to DFA Amaya at this early stage of the season? In the short term, Tristan Gray and José Devers should get most of the shortstop reps for the Jumbo Shrimp. I'll wait to see where Amaya lands and what the Marlins get in return for him before rushing the judgement, but this looks on the surface like an unforced sell-low situation. -
It has been unfortunately commonplace for fringy pitchers to be used this way. It may in some cases lead guys to give more serious consideration to pitching in foreign leagues instead of MLB/MiLB, but the Marlins aren't the only ones cycling through them in this manner.
- 6 replies
-
- mike trout
- max meyer
-
(and 3 more)
Tagged with:

