Marlins did just enough at trade deadline to keep fans interested

[Sean Millerick]

Another MLB trade deadline, another round of waiting for the other shoe to drop for Miami Marlins fans. 

Despite a terrific week of play that propelled Miami to three games over .500 and within 1.5 games of a playoff spot as Monday's deadline approached, all that had been reported was how Miami was listening to offers on players who had been vital to getting them to this point. The odds seemed high that deadline day transactions would leave them with a substantially weaker 2026 roster. It would have been deflating to essentially bow out of the race in early August with a winning team, especially being as starved for success starved as this franchise is.

The front office did the bare minimum early on by shutting down any speculation about Sandy Alcantara and Eury Perez being available. Two out of every five games, the Marlins will continue deploying starting pitchers with the upside to thoroughly dominate.

Griffin Conine is famously in Marlin circles "not a Bendix guy", and therefore has often been viewed as more expendable than other outfielders in the organization. Even so, you can't trade the son of Mr. Marlin. Not this early in his career, anyway, especially not when the underlying numbers suggest he might also just be really good at the whole playing baseball thing.

The Marlins instead parted with Liam Hicks to address their glut of left-handed hitters. That has understandably upset a portion of the fanbase, but Hicks may well have been superfluous between Joe Mack's emergence and the fact Agustin Ramirez is technically a catcher. 

Crucially, the team's greatest strength remains intact. Middle infielders Otto Lopez and Xavier Edwards are both above-average defenders capable of stretches of outstanding offense. Dealing Edwards would have been a major blow, as would dealing Lopez, which would've also come with the baggage of dealing a reigning All-Star. "Selling high" is not a satisfactory justification for trading either when there aren't obvious replacements waiting in the wings.

It was by no means an aggressive deadline for the Marlins, but they proceeded appropriately given the circumstances. There is a sense right now that every game counts. Nothing is more important to growing their brand. 

Seasons like this one have just been too few and far between for Marlins fans. The 2026 team has a chance. It might not be a big one, but again, this kind of thing is all relative. Compared to Marlins' seasons past, this club is a borderline juggernaut. 

Consider this writer thrilled about the deadline day decisions. Now the Wild Card chase can continue, with the future of the Marlins looking bright as well. 

View full article

[Hans Herrera]

I'm going to sound a lot like Alex Ligero, but I don't agree with the "but the Marlins are at least giving themselves a chance to compete down the stretch."

I would say: "The Marlins expect/hope to keep competing by leaning on Caissie/Conine to provide Hicks-level production AND stay alive for the Wild Card race with a duct-taped rotation beyond Sandy and Eury."

I get the "sustainable future" process, but the prospects acquired are more quantity than quality. Sure, some of them are pretty interesting, but none of them is expected to be an impactful starter... maybe Beck and probably (hopefully) Taylor.

Hicks, on the other hand, is an impactful starter and should probably had made it to the ASG. I get it, I get the reasons for trading him. In fact, the Marlins got a bag for him, but you don't see any ambition to "go for it" now, or anytime soon anyway.

Maybe the Marlins make this postseason, but only to lose during the first or second round. This is not an LCS team, period. Then the offseason comes, and we'll still be waiting for the big FA signing, which never happens. We then still hope Caissie turns into a 40-HR threat, Stowers can stay healthy and knock another 30. The rotation will hopefully look like Sandy-Eury-Max-Junk-Phillips, with us can't wait to see Snelling, White, and Sandy extended.

Guess what? The Padres or White Sox are going to come with a "ridiculous package" for Alcántara and then he's gone. Then the same rhetoric of "the sustainable future" crap. Then they sign Quintana for 1-Year, $2,5 M to keep us interested. Early in the season, Junk needs TJ (God forbid). Snelling and White will be ready around June. By then it is too late, and here we go again: trading Otto, X, and Stowers, which is BS; they will be traded because they hit Arb years. They'd rather "restock" the farm and "do enough to keep fans interested".

Like I said, a lot like that guy Ligero. It is just really frustrating to have a legitimate chance to be good and decide not to because you hope to be better next year and for years to come. The only teams doing that lately are LAD, NYY, ATL, HOU, and MIL. (2nd, 3rd, 6th, 8th, and 19th in payroll budget this year).

Javel. I hope Alex and I are wrong.

[1993 fan from start]

first of its not only about Griffen. who never play for marlins till Peter Bendix gave him a chance.   The guy that trusted him first .  and how long did it take for Griffen to GET CALL UP? Who do you think Griffen and Jeff  trust more? the guy that traded for him and never call him up in 3 years. or the guy that call him up . In his first year on the job.     Griffen is more a Peter Bendix guy then you think.  And that main none of us are Bendix guys . Even if we trust him on day one over past people.

Marlins did just enough at trade deadline to keep fans interested I disagree How many of the returns going to make big impact this year?  same problem marlins had during the losing streak still with them.    so it was a  EVEN KILL FOR ME .  Hicks only trade I thougth was worth it. and giving Bendix trust in other trades. but one I don't agree with. .Don’t look for May to take the mound in a MLB game any time soon,

Caissie/Conine to provide Hicks-level production lol  more like Javier Sanoja/Esteury Ruiz the way the trades went done .  its time for Javier Sanoja to step it up  do I  think he surpasses his run total of 40 in 2025 no  Marlins still have LOSING record when he hits above 9th in order.

[Jose Herrera]

Looks like trading Hicks & Norby will clear playing time for D.D.L.S & Gus going forward. Trading Bachar will now open a spot for Jack Ralston or Josh White. Victor Vodnik is a decent insurance option in case Fairbanks flames out.

All in all, I give the front office a B+. I'm excited to see what all our new players will do. Plus, the new roles existing players will take on. The Hicks’s trade was cool because we flipped a former rule 5 pick for two first rounders and legitimate pitching prospect. Shoot all the prospects we picked up are solid.

[THOMAS JOSEPH]

I tend to agree with the article premise for three reasons. 

The Marlins have positioned themselves quite well going into the CBA - because they had to. It's a team-friendly roster composition of absolute sustainability because the new framework, simply put, is a final opportunity to correct the MLB ecosystem after the devastating RSN collapse. Once settled, Bendix has the flexibility to move in any direction.

Any playoff possibility has emerged as a longshot with 49 games remaining. Of course, anything can happen. Still, the strength of the NL this year portends one WC spot is realistically competitive. We're not overtaking the Phillies or Cubs.  It's Lloyd Christmas' "so you're telling me there is a chance."

Finally, none of the deadline moves were irreplaceable pieces, reflected a primarily financial component, or disrupted the overall excellent team chemistry. I think the article title properly sums up the team's middling position vis-á-vis any postseason hopes (light), while incrementally continuing to improve awaiting the (hopefully) salvific CBA. 

There's no where else to go until the agreement is settled. Too many long-term problems are systemic, that is, out of the control of the team entirely. I am weary of drawing to inside straights and being labeled with some form of inane "surprisingly competitive" balderdash from the ridiculous media parrots. 

[Jose Herrera]

@Hans Herrera That behavior is more than likely a thing of the past. This may be Bro-Science but if a salary cap & floor come out of the C.B.A this offseason then we will HAVE to spend money.

Alcantara, Edwards & Lopez will all be great options to extend to raise our salary floor.

[Jose Herrera]

@THOMAS JOSEPH I think we can sneak up on anyone, but the Padres did get much better. Mize & Ray😵‍💫

[Shawn]

It’s the same BS as always, bunch of maybes for the future been the same since this cheap ass owner don’t since buying the team. It’s not going to change they don’t spend what the CBA says that have to spend do to revenue sharing. There nothing but a farm team that’s never going to compete. I’ll wait till stowers and Lopez are traded over the offseason to completely give up on being a marlins fan. 33 years of this bullshit is enough. Glad you drank the kool aid and continue talking about the future being hearing that since the 2017 teardown.