Jump to content
Fish On First
  • Create Account
  • What do you tell a Marlins fan who just awoke from a 3-year coma?

    With an overhauled roster and completely new front office, the current Marlins would look unrecognizable to somebody who's been out of the loop since their 2023 postseason appearance.

    Louis Addeo-Weiss
    Image courtesy of Bryan Cereijo/Getty Images

    It's Wednesday, October 4, 2023. Game 2 of the NL Wild Card Series.

    Jazz Chisholm Jr. takes a 100 mph fastball from Gregory Soto for a called strike three, ending arguably the most thoroughly enjoyable season of Miami Marlins baseball since their miracle 2003 World Series run.

    As a lifelong Marlins fan whose journey with the club has been tumultuous over the past two decades, you feel grateful just to see your favorite team back in the postseason and optimistic about what lies ahead. Kim Ng had a breakout year as the club's general manager while rookie manager Skip Schumaker has already established himself as one of the best in the business.

    Then, as you wean off the highs the season brought, tragedy strikes. 

    Playing left field in your office softball league, a fly ball comes your way. You start backpedaling and accelerate to full speed, thinking you have a pretty good shot at making a game-saving catch, but instead, your next point of contact is the outfield wall. 

    Down you go.

    Your teammates initially snicker at your blooper before doing the socially acceptable courtesy of checking to ensure you are okay. When you fail to respond to any of their cues, the courtesy turns to concern. 

    The dreaded 9-1-1 is dialed, and twenty minutes on, you find yourself in a hospital bed. Doctors ultimately determine that you sustained a concussion and slipped into a coma.

    The sun rises the following day; you still remain unconscious. A week later, still nothing. Months pass by, then years and you're stuck in a vegetative state.

    Still, your family stands by your side, holding out hope that you'll someday resume a life of loving them, and of course, following the Fish.

     


    It is now November 2026. It's been 37 months of pure external silence when suddenly your eyes slowly open.

    Your first thought is the obvious: "Where am I?" You turn your eyes to see your loved ones, now all riddled with tears, as the confusion persists.

    You can tell a lot of time has elapsed, so naturally, the first question that comes out of your mouth is, "How are the Marlins?"

    Performance-wise, very little changed about the franchise during your absence. Miami's 2026 record was four games worse than in 2023, but the club scored more runs while allowing fewer, once again culminating in a third-place finish in the National League East standings.

    However, outside of Bruce Sherman's continued reign as owner and Sandy Alcantara's reemergence as MLB's premier innings eater, practically everything is different.

    "How is Skip doing managing the club?"

    Imagine getting a recap of that passive-aggressive divorce, finalized less than one year after Schumaker was named NL Manager of the Year.

    "Oh, and what about Kim?"

    You wouldn't believe that Ng has left the baseball world entirely after Sherman was hesitant to have her continue leading the front office.

    "Okay, so how did they finish 2024?" 

    New president of baseball operations Peter Bendix mostly stood pat with the playoff-caliber roster that he inherited, but pulled the plug after an ice-cold start to the season.

    Luis Arraez was dealt to the Padres after a mere 33 games. The trade was widely panned for the next season-and-a-half, but it turns out Jakob Marsee may be a fair consolation after all for the loss of a perennial batting title contender.

    Most notable in a series of trade deadline moves, they traded Jazz to the Yankees...and he played in the World Series that same year.

    "Did Edward Cabrera finally put it all together?"

    Only briefly. Miami sold high on Cabby following a career-best 2025 season by trading him to the Chicago Cubs. He posted a 5.96 ERA in 18 appearances for his new team.

    "I guess we're left with Sandy and Jesús Luzardo, right?"

    How does one break the news that the Marlins did the opposite with Luzardo, gifting him to the rival Phillies when his stock had dropped? Not only did he place fifth in NL Cy Young voting, but his new contract extension runs through the next half-decade.

    Starlyn Caba will make a fine utility infielder if it all pans out. 

    Although Tommy John surgery slowed his career progression, Eury Pérez at least has the upside to fill the Luzardo void.

    You would be pleased to hear that Alcantara has etched his name all over the Marlins' record books, becoming their all-time leader in strikeouts and innings pitched, and that you will see more of him in a Marlins uniform. His $21 million club option has been exercised for 2027. Perhaps it would make you chuckle to learn that he has more saves (three) than complete games (one) since your accident.

    "What other All-Star talent are we building around?"

    You wouldn't believe that Kyle Stowers earned a selection in 2025 and a former waiver claim, Otto Lopez, is now one of the sport's most well-rounded shortstops. They have helped elevate the Marlins' notoriously mediocre offense to competence. 

    The long-awaited breakout of Max Meyer occurred, too. No, not as a reliever—the Marlins gave him another shot to stick in the starting rotation and he joined Lopez as an All-Star in 2026, though yet another injury sidelined him for most of the second half. 

    "Well, who is steering the ship now?"

    Clayton McCullough defied expectations in his first two seasons as manager by flirting with returns to October despite being hamstrung by MLB's lowest payroll. On the other hand, numerous questionable in-game decisions seemingly held the Marlins back from winning even more games. He'll be returning to the dugout for a third year.

    And finally...

    "What are realistic expectations for the Marlins in 2027?"

    Your guess would be as good as anybody's given the uncertainty of whether Major League Baseball will be played at all.

    There will be plenty of time to catch up on more of what you missed—Marlins-related and otherwise—when the lockout begins next month.

    When will 2027 Opening Day take place?

    Follow Fish On First For Miami Marlins News & Analysis

    Think you could write a story like this? Fish On First wants you to develop your voice and find an audience. We recruit our paid front page writers from our users blogs section. Start a blog today!

    More From Fish On First
    — Latest Marlins coverage from our writers
    — Recent Marlins discussion in our forums
    — Become a Fish On First SuperSub

    Recent Marlins Articles

    Recent Marlins Videos

    Marlins Top Prospects

    Dillon Lewis

    Pensacola Blue Wahoos - AA, OF
    In 19 Arizona Fall League games, Marlins prospect Dillon Lewis slashed .264/.329/.389 with a home run and 14 RBI. He started 12 of those games in center field.

    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments

    Featured Comments



    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...