Starting pitchers the Marlins could've signed instead of Cal Quantrill

[Ely Sussman]

I'm not implying that the Marlins are already feeling buyer's remorse about their new right-hander. Just out of curiosity, let's peruse the list of other potential starters who received Quantrill-esque contracts from MLB teams this past offseason.

It needed to be done. After trading Jesús Luzardo and losing Braxton Garrett to season-ending surgery, the Miami Marlins had insufficient starting rotation depth for 2025. Regardless of how little the team cares about winning games this upcoming season amidst a rebuild, you still have to participate in them, ideally without rushing prospects to the major leagues or stretching unqualified depth players beyond their reasonable limits.

Enter Cal Quantrill. The Canadian right-hander is only a couple years removed from starting playoff games. He owned a solid 3.88 ERA and 7.2% walk rate in his MLB career prior to last season's brutal second-half slump. Getting his services for a $3.5 million guarantee with up to $500,000 in performance bonuses is a bargain for the Fish.

Which other stopgap starters were available in free agency for a comparable price? I consulted the MLB Trade Rumors contract tracker to generate the following list of pitchers with recent rotation experience who signed guaranteed major league deals worth $5 million or less during the 2024-25 offseason.

Kyle Hendricks is the most accomplished of the bunch. He peaked as the National League ERA leader nearly a decade ago. For much of his career since then, Hendricks has produced like a high-end No. 3 starter, though he's coming off a nightmarish 2024 campaign and can't top 90 mph anymore.

Martín Pérez is a boring yet safe floor-raiser with 13 years of MLB experience and a deep pitch mix.

Griffin Canning shouldered the heaviest workload last season (171.2 IP), following closely by Colin Rea (167.2 IP).

The track records of Jakob Junis, Shinnosuke Ogasawara, Joe Ross and Bryse Wilson suggest they will be moved back and forth between the rotation and bullpen throughout the year depending on their teams' needs.

Considering these alternatives, I have to admit that the Marlins chose well. As long as they can resolve the uncharacteristic control issues that derailed Quantrill last summer, he is as likely as anybody else on this list eat to valuable innings and do so effectively enough to appeal to contending teams come the trade deadline when Miami will be shopping for prospects.

Of course, there was a wider universe of arms to choose from if the Marlins weren't so frugal. It would have been difficult to recruit future Hall of Famers Max Scherzer ($15.5M) or Justin Verlander ($15M) to a team of this caliber, but what about Alex Cobb ($15M), Tomoyuki Sugano ($13M) or Mike Soroka ($9M), who also signed one-year deals with no strings attached beyond 2025? I say it's fair game to cite them in this conversation as well.

View full article

[rurrusuno]

Kyle Hendricks would've been my go-to guy as well. Sucks he can't hit the 90s anymore, which is a red flag. Martin Perez is a good safe option

[Slacker Mills]

Glad you brought up this subject. If you're in the market for crap starter with pretty clear upside, Quantrill was a MUCH better choice than Nick Pivetta.  San Diego just agreed to give Pivetta $55m over four years! He's older than Cal by two years and pretty much matches his numbers.

[One Regend]

1 hour ago, Slacker Mills said:

Glad you brought up this subject. If you're in the market for crap starter with pretty clear upside, Quantrill was a MUCH better choice than Nick Pivetta.  San Diego just agreed to give Pivetta $55m over four years! He's older than Cal by two years and pretty much matches his numbers.

Pivetta was always a someone who had outstanding peripherals but never had the results to back it up. He's a constant headache to whoever team has him for that reason. He clearly has the talent, but has never been able to live up to potential.

That said, I think the Padres grossly overspent on him. They've gotten beaten by other teams on a variety of Free Agents, and their deal with Nick Pivetta speaks more about their desperation to sign somebody, rather than how good Nick Pivetta actually is.

[BMK3]

I do not see Patrick Corbin anywhere here.  He is probably getting cheaper by the day.  He finished strong last year and adding another lefty to create stability for only the beginning of this year before hopefully moving him seems like a good idea to me.  Small risk, possible reward.

[Hans Herrera]

Quantrill is still in his prime (just turned 30 a week ago) and looks like a few tweaks here and there can give the team 150ish innings of 4ish ERA ball. I think anyone can take that any day.

I would have taken Pérez instead but my no means this was a wrong choice. Canning would have been interesting as well.

How much would you pay for Quintana as of today?

[THOMAS JOSEPH]

At least, we don't have Marcus Stroman on the roster. 

[One Regend]

2 minutes ago, THOMAS JOSEPH said:

At least, we don't have Marcus Stroman on the roster. 

The last thing this rebuild needs is a PR mess. The less distractions this team has, the better.