Miami Marlins may soon need to decide upon their shortstop of the future

[Sean Millerick]

Has the future arrived for the Miami Marlins at shortstop? Or is the best yet to come? 

For my money, that's the biggest decision facing Miami's front office over the next five weeks, far more than any decision regarding staff ace Sandy Alcantara. Granted, that's because the Alcantara decision has never been a question for me— he should be viewed as untouchable, at least until clarity arrives on the league's salary situation next season. Shortstop, though? There's a ton for Peter Bendix to chew on between now and the trade deadline. 

At the center of the puzzle is Otto Lopez , the obvious choice to start at shortstop for the National League for anyone with eyes that isn't a fan of the Dodgers, Nationals, Phillies, or Reds. The MLB hits leader is having a career year. Lopez has either suddenly become one of the best shortstops in all of baseball or is simply having one heck of a flash in the pan effort as this season's Geraldo Perdomo. 

He doesn't even hit arbitration until next season. He's not a free agent until 2030. He was basically free for the Marlins to obtain in the first place, plucked from obscurity in what is becoming the best transaction of the Bendix era. Most importantly though, Lopez is working on his third straight season of being an above average MLB regular. Even if he ends up "only" being his 3.3 WAR 2025 self, he's worth keeping around for a team trying to win. 

Two problems on that score.

The first problem is that two of Miami's Top 6 prospects, and two of their Top 3 healthy ones, are shortstops. Aiva Arquette and Starlyn Caba are both having strong seasons. Obviously, that's one of those problems that isn't really a problem at all for the Marlins front office. Yet it does mean that sooner than later, barring major injury, someone is either getting moved off their position or moved off the roster entirely. 

And then there's the second problem- are the Miami Marlins ultimately going to try to win right now? 

Even if if the answer there is "not until 2027", there's a strong case to be made for keeping Lopez given his contract situation. He is exactly the kind of player low payroll clubs like the Marlins need- cheap and controllable. Then again, just as strong of a case can be made that he will never be worth more than is right now. 

If Miami remains in the Wild Card race, all of this is moot. He won't be going anywhere. If they fall out of it though, it's really going to be fascinating to see how Bendix views Lopez. Is Lopez proof of concept that he can routinely go bargain-bin shopping for players? Or does he think he found a keeper here? 

Of course, if Lopez is a keeper and Miami is competing, that puts the team in the likely position of needing to add talent at the deadline. 

It's hard to see any truly impact upgrade not costing the Marlins one of Arquette or Caba. 

They can't trade a pitcher. They probably need Kemp Alderman this year. That really narrows the field of choices for Bendix to dangle to rival GMs. Outfield is deep, sure, but no one at the MLB level is doing the kind of position blocking Lopez is doing right now. Especially not if the team keeps transforming Kyle Stowers into a first baseman. Plus, none of those names carry the kind of cache a well-regarded shortstop prospect would.  If Miami does actually buy, they may well buy big. That means a top prospect, and again, only the shortstops are healthy. 

As to which of those young talents the team should trade? I'll leave that call to far brighter prospect minds than my own. Fortunately for your reading interest, many of them work for this very website. All I know is there is virtually no world in which two of them are moved this summer, buying or selling. 

However, I do think it's safe to say that the time is fast approaching that the Marlins will have to decide who their shortstop of the future isn't going to be. When the team decides who the odd man out at shortstop is, Marlins fans shouldn't be surprised if they are moved in the team's biggest deadline deal. 

 

View full article