Jump to content
Fish On First
  • Create Account
  • Marlins took 'real steps' in 2025 despite falling short in Wild Card race

    The Marlins played Thursday's game with playoff intensity, but their bats went cold at an inconvenient time. After 159 games, they've been mathematically eliminated from contention.

    Kevin Barral
    Image courtesy of Terence Lewis/Icon Sportswire

    Marlins Video

    The Miami Marlins were eliminated from 2025 postseason contention following their 1-0 loss to the Philadelphia Phillies on Thursday. The fact that the previous sentence was written on September 25 is a credit to manager Clayton McCullough, the coaching staff and all the players who contributed this season. A team that was almost universally projected to finish with 70 wins or fewer currently stands at 77-82 with three games remaining to spoil the New York Mets' Wild Card chances.

    "We set out from spring training that our number one focus was going to be to just try to get better every day and try to raise the floor—not only of the players that we were gonna have on the roster at a given time and try to get everybody a little bit better as we went along, but also our staff and players creating a culture and put something in a place that we believe is gonna lead to sustainability. " McCullough said postgame. "While disappointing to get here and know that our season is going to end on Sunday, doesn't take away from taking a step back and a 30,000-foot view on so many what we feel like were real steps that we took throughout this season and the strides that a lot of our players have made."

    After being limited to one total (unearned) run by the previous two Phillies starting pitchers, the Marlins offense didn't fare any better against Walker Buehler. Signed by the Phillies to a minor league deal less than a month ago, Buehler went five innings, allowing three hits, three walks and struck out two on 74 pitches.

    Taijuan Walker followed him by throwing two innings, allowing only one hit and struck out three. Matt Strahm and David Robertson handled the eighth and ninth innings, respectively.

    It was the 10th time this season that the Marlins have been shut out. They did a good job making contact, but only collected eight hard-hit balls. They had no extra-base hits, though Agustín Ramírez came close with a 114 mph line drive off the left field wall.

    It was a short leash for Marlins starting pitcher Janson Junk, going 4 ⅔ innings. He only surrendered one run on five hits, no walks and struck out four.

    In the bottom of the first inning, Junk allowed a leadoff single to outfielder Harrison Bader, then struck out Kyle Schwarber and allowed a second base hit, this time to Bryce Harper, who was making his first appearance this series. Alec Bohm grounded out, but Bader was able to score. Junk went on to retire eight straight before Harper had his second hit of the night.

    Junk was signed to a minor league deal and initially sent down to Triple-A Jacksonville. The Marlins selected his contract on May 24. Early on, he was used in long relief, not making his first start with the team until June 20 against the Atlanta Braves. He will finish the season posting a 4.17 ERA and a 3.15 FIP through 110 innings pitched as a big leaguer. Per the team, Junk walked just 13 of the 447 batters, posting a 2.9 BB%, the lowest mark in MLB this season and the best single-season mark in club history (min. 100 IP).

    "He goes out there and fills it up," said McCullough. "He did exactly what we needed tonight...Great season for Janson and another start where we got what we needed."

    It's rare to get that kind of production from somebody acquired on a non-guaranteed contract. The only other minor league free agent signing from last offseason to pitch over 100 innings in 2025 was Toronto Blue Jays starter Eric Lauer, who finished the regular season with 103 ⅔ innings pitched, posting a 3.21 ERA and 3.88 FIP.

    It's unclear what role Junk will have with the Marlins in 2026. He is out of minor league options, so that positions him well to make the active roster even with talented arms coming back from injuries and making the case to be promoted from Triple-A.

    "We know Janson can (start or pitch out of the bullpen)," said McCullough pregame. "We'll come into spring training not knowing what the landscape is going to look like next year, but we will get Janson prepared to be a starter for us going into spring training, someone who's going to be on our team next year in some capacity. Those are just questions that we will answer down the road."

    In the bottom of the sixth inning, the Marlins deployed Ronny Henriquez, who struck out both Max Kepler and Harrison Bader swinging. Per the Marlins, it marked his 59th appearance with at least one strikeout, tying the club record shared by Kyle Barraclough (2016) and Tanner Scott (2023).

    The Marlins finish their season against the New York Mets with Sandy Alcantara taking the mound on Friday opposing rookie Brandon Sproat. First pitch is at 7:10 pm.

    "We're going to go home, have our last three, go out and try to win each one of those games and go about it in a very similar manner," said McCullough.

    Should the Marlins continue trying to develop Agustín Ramírez as a catcher?

    Follow Fish On First For Miami Marlins News & Analysis

    Think you could write a story like this? Fish On First wants you to develop your voice and find an audience. We recruit our paid front page writers from our users blogs section. Start a blog today!

    More From Fish On First
    — Latest Marlins coverage from our writers
    — Recent Marlins discussion in our forums
    — Become a Fish On First SuperSub

    Recent Marlins Articles

    Recent Marlins Videos

    Marlins Top Prospects

    Karson Milbrandt

    Pensacola Blue Wahoos - AA, RHP
    Karson Milbrandt matched his professional career high by going six strong innings on Saturday. Dating back to last year, he has posted a 1.86 ERA through his first six starts at Double-A.

    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments

    Featured Comments

    ? jumk or about marlins wild card or about last night game?

    great season junk and a keeper

    The Marlins did not play Thursday's game with playoff intensity,  when you lost big time and shown you had no real desire two win rest of season .  by leating Javier Sanoja pich again.  

    Can you imagine where the Marlins would be right now if Bendix and Moron McCullough didn't blow a whole bunch of games in April and August? They could have EASILY won another 8 to 10 games if they acted like they were ACTUALLY TRYING TO WIN GAMES rather than just fooling around, experimenting with different lineups and pitchers in the rotation. Two things were obvious this year. When the season started, management had the mindset that they had no chance to be contenders this year. Then in early August when the team shocked EVERYONE (INCLUDING BENDIX & THE MORON!) by getting back to .500,, management threw in the towel instead of going all out and trying to make a real run for a playoff spot. While other teams were bringing up young players that could help, the Marlins stayed with Josh Simpson, Zuber, and George Soriano in the bullpen. They brought up Troy Johnston and then hardly played him, while continuing to play Wagaman constantly. Troy hit so well that they eventually gave him more ABs, and Wagaman, despite finally hitting a little better this month still has no power and is a minus defensively. 

    This team's PLAYERS overcame a lot of bad moves by the management, Bendix and McCullough both. I credit the players, not management. 

     

    Marlins rookie PLAYERS deserve a lot of credit for this season for overcoming a lot of really bad managing. I will give you one example from July. Marlins playing KC Royals in a tie game going to extra innings. KC starts the inning with the placed runner on second base, then with two outs has runners on 2nd and 3rd, game is still tied. Right hand pitcher Lake Bachar is pitching. First base is open. KC sends up a Pinch Hitting Specialist, a lefty hitter who has a BA of almost .500 against right hand pitchers. Remember, First base is OPEN! The TV announcers say that the Marlins will definitely walk this lefty hitting pinch hitter stud. But no! Moron McCullough tells Lake to pitch to him! What happened? The guy doubles, driving in 2 runs; Lake strikes out the next guy, a right hand hitter. Marlins are supposed to lose, right? Wrong! In the bottom of the 10 inning the Fish score THREE RUNS to win the game. This is a game that perfectly represents the season that the 2025 Marlins had. If you don't like this one, pick any game where McCullough pulled out a starter with 2 outs in the bottom of the 5th and brought in some bum who then blew the game.

    1 hour ago, Alex Ligero said:

    Can you imagine where the Marlins would be right now if Bendix and Moron McCullough didn't blow a whole bunch of games in April and August? They could have EASILY won another 8 to 10 games if they acted like they were ACTUALLY TRYING TO WIN GAMES rather than just fooling around, experimenting with different lineups and pitchers in the rotation. Two things were obvious this year. When the season started, management had the mindset that they had no chance to be contenders this year. Then in early August when the team shocked EVERYONE (INCLUDING BENDIX & THE MORON!) by getting back to .500,, management threw in the towel instead of going all out and trying to make a real run for a playoff spot. While other teams were bringing up young players that could help, the Marlins stayed with Josh Simpson, Zuber, and George Soriano in the bullpen. They brought up Troy Johnston and then hardly played him, while continuing to play Wagaman constantly. Troy hit so well that they eventually gave him more ABs, and Wagaman, despite finally hitting a little better this month still has no power and is a minus defensively. 

    This team's PLAYERS overcame a lot of bad moves by the management, Bendix and McCullough both. I credit the players, not management. 

     

    I agree that the players need to be applauded for rising from the cellar to 3rd place ahead of the Braves and within striking distance of the Mets and the 3rd wildcard. All of those bone headed moves thru-out the season by Skip McCullough and his pitching coaches came back to haunt the team at the end when we needed a few more wins. They tinkered with and messed up Sandy early costing us 4 or 5 wins right there. Pulling SP's in the 4th and 5th innings just when they were getting in a groove wasn't smart either as you instead cooked our bullpen sending Bender, Tinoco and others to the golf courses early. Ronnie Henriquez couldn't be used regularly by the end of the season too instead giving us a front row seat in September to the rocket launcher Lake Bachar. 🚀 How many meaningful home runs did he serve up coming in to pitch in close games that we needed a hold on? We never intentionally walked a superstar until Schwarber the other night and they all made us pay dearly late in games with clutch hitting and his walk was the wrong call again as he ended up scoring the tying run. Our young players I applaud 👏 for their preparation, heart and determination to find a way to win despite all the misguided mistakes their manager and mgmt made. Never say die for sure! I really enjoyed watching these kids fight this season despite these negatives because of the success they were able to have from July on. As with other teams, we gave away at least 10 games this year. Hopefully going forward into 2026 Mgmt realizes what went wrong and aims to correct it so we have a better chance to win those games going forward and become a playoff team. Also, we need a real veteran 1st Baseman and not projects or just put Gus Ramirez there because his glove is not slick enough to handle catcher but his bat is definitely major league ready.

    5 hours ago, Alex Ligero said:

    Marlins rookie PLAYERS deserve a lot of credit for this season for overcoming a lot of really bad managing. I will give you one example from July. Marlins playing KC Royals in a tie game going to extra innings. KC starts the inning with the placed runner on second base, then with two outs has runners on 2nd and 3rd, game is still tied. Right hand pitcher Lake Bachar is pitching. First base is open. KC sends up a Pinch Hitting Specialist, a lefty hitter who has a BA of almost .500 against right hand pitchers. Remember, First base is OPEN! The TV announcers say that the Marlins will definitely walk this lefty hitting pinch hitter stud. But no! Moron McCullough tells Lake to pitch to him! What happened? The guy doubles, driving in 2 runs; Lake strikes out the next guy, a right hand hitter. Marlins are supposed to lose, right? Wrong! In the bottom of the 10 inning the Fish score THREE RUNS to win the game. This is a game that perfectly represents the season that the 2025 Marlins had. If you don't like this one, pick any game where McCullough pulled out a starter with 2 outs in the bottom of the 5th and brought in some bum who then blew the game.

    Honestly, you don't even need to look that far back for a game like that. The Tuesday game against the Phillies this week on its own was a microcosm of the entire season.

    -Xavier Edwards stole 2 bases yet none of them counted because Eric Wagaman had the situational awareness of an ostrich. McCullough couldve relayed signs to Wagaman to take the first few pitches to allow Edwards a chance to advance into 2nd base. This was during a time JT Realmuto was visibly hurt and wasn't in any condition to make good throws.
    -Intentionally walks Kyle Schwarber in the 10th inning. Prior to Wednesday, we held Schwarber to a .182 BA with 0 HRs. The worst he could've done was tie the game with a HR.
    -Not only did the guy after Schwarber drive a run in, not only did it create a winning run scenario, but McCullough brought in Josh Simpson -- a guy who hasn't proven he can get major league hitters out, to have a lefty-lefty matchup. The problem? The Phillies still had Nick Castellanos on the bench.

    Those were all rookie mistakes, and I'm shocked they all didn't blow up in McCullough's face. The Marlins ended up winning that game in spite of McCullough's moves.

    McCullough seems to get stuck on favorites:

    1. Hicks at cleanup

    2. Wagaman plays against righties (against anybody)

    3. Faucher is our closer

    4. Simpson is allowed to wear a uniform

    No experimenting for next season:

    1. Henriquez as closer or more than one inning

    2. Johnston more time against lefties which he hit well in the minors. Start at 1B

    3. Pauley and Acosta move all over the field without getting time to settle in at their preferred positions.

    Base running errors that coaches should have been in player's ears about before hand: Just last 3 games

    1. Marsee trying to steal 3rd with 1 out down 2 runs

    2. Wagaman not aware Edwards might steal

    3. Ramirez not knowing there is only 1 out. Doubled up on a pop up

    4. Johnston out by a mile at home



    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...