Jump to content
Fish On First
  • Create Account
  • entries
    11
  • comments
    30
  • views
    45,371

Some personal takes about the season


Marlins Video

Everything you are about to read represents my gut feeling and nothing more.

1. Yes, the Marlines overachieved, but many losses were plain stubbornness (and some wins were pure luck, honestly)

Why did they bother with the Edwards to SS for SO LONG, when it was obvious Otto López was the man to handle the position? How many times, we the fans, witnessed excruciating bullpen decisions? Is there any way to convince these people that Agustín Ramírez is not an MLB catcher? I just don't love McCullough. I do acknowledge he has an AMAZING team around him, but sometimes they were forcing things when there was absolutely no need to.

2. We all loved the Gus Bus, but...

And I'm not even talking about the catching part. Yes, he hit 21 HRs. Yes, he is definitely a threat when in the batter's box. He for sure will get some ROY votes. My concern is about the quality of many, many ABs. Often, he looked overmatched. High chase rate, low BB%. He did not show those flaws in AAA... a lot to work with him this offseason.

3. All eyes are on getting a 1B, but can we do something about 3B?

Pete Alonso, Josh Naylor, Ryan O'Hearn... they are not happening (#BringBackLewinDiaz). The solution is so simple that I won't even mention it. Late in the season, it looked like Wags finally found it. Johnston should give decent numbers if an extended opportunity opens for him. So, can we talk about yet ANOTHER experiment? Norby can play the position once or twice a week, but no more than that, and his bat is not helping his cause anyway. Pauley is an outstanding glove, but his best-case scenario is a 105 OPS+ bat.

4. Bullpen, bullpen, and more bullpen arms

Henriquez, amazing. Bachar, Gibson, Faucher, and Phillips, solid but unspectacular. Bender got injured when most needed (not his fault, obviously). This bullpen needs a 99+ mph-Ryan Helsley-type of guy. The aforementioned six people, plus Nardi, plus Meyer (I think he will take the long-reliever role next year, barring injuries and/or multiple trades), plus a bona fide closer, and you got a pretty solid bullpen. José Alvarado? David Robertson at least? Anyone? Are you going to be THAT cheap, Bruce?

5. Offseason besties for trades

There is a 90% probability that the Front Office is going to trade away a Starter. However, given the roster crunch the team is facing when the Rule 5 deadline approaches, there are some teams the Marlins should contact in order to strike a deal. For example, I liked what I saw from Halvorsen, Vodnik, and Mejía in Colorado. Or maybe the White Sox, having Taylor and Leasure as strikeout guys in the bullpen. Those are two out of three teams that were WORSE than the Marlins in OPS from their first basemen, and Troy Johnston is a potential trade candidate, as much as I hate to admit it. At least ONE of those names should be available via trade, right?

3 Comments


Recommended Comments

One Regend

Posted

I think for the Marlins to be competitive in 2026, they're going to need a closer, and they're going to need a 3B.

Ryan Helsley got BTFO'd when he wore a Mets uniform, but how much of that was Ryan Helsley, and how much of that is the Mets organization? A lot of the tipping he did was obvious and yet the Mets organization did nothing about it. I'd say he's worth taking a flyer on.

The Twins have a couple of potential 3Bs, and as a rebuilding team, they have the runway and the long leash to get Troy Johnston some ABs. Do you think the Marliins would buy low on a Brooks Lee? Or do they go big and throw in another prospect to get Royce Lewis? Either way, the Marlins aren't going after high-end free agent 3Bs, so their best chance is through trades.

Slacker Mills

Posted

I am all for signing Lewin Diaz. He may have discovered something with his bat overseas and his glove has always been golden.

Hans Herrera

Posted

On 10/6/2025 at 4:21 AM, One Regend said:

I think for the Marlins to be competitive in 2026, they're going to need a closer, and they're going to need a 3B.

Ryan Helsley got BTFO'd when he wore a Mets uniform, but how much of that was Ryan Helsley, and how much of that is the Mets organization? A lot of the tipping he did was obvious and yet the Mets organization did nothing about it. I'd say he's worth taking a flyer on.

The Twins have a couple of potential 3Bs, and as a rebuilding team, they have the runway and the long leash to get Troy Johnston some ABs. Do you think the Marliins would buy low on a Brooks Lee? Or do they go big and throw in another prospect to get Royce Lewis? Either way, the Marlins aren't going after high-end free agent 3Bs, so their best chance is through trades.

I don't see the Twins as an obvious trade partner for a 3B. Lewis had a lot of trouble with the glove, and Lee is more a SS. They have a bunch of 2B/Utility players to shuffle around, but not a solid 3B. Besides, MIN looks more and more like a rebuilding team.

Teams that might have a "surplus" of 3Bmen are: Texas (Jung, Smith), Toronto (Barger, Clement), and maybe the amazing Mets (Baty, Vientos, and Mauricio)... but are any of those players actually desirable? I would say Barger is the most solid one, followed by Baty. Then, is there a clear way for a trade between Miami and Toronto or NY? I think Barger is more expensive than the Marlins would like to send back, and there is no way we are trading with the Mets,

If they bring Lewin Díaz on an extremely incentive-loaded contract (Minor league contract with an invitation to ST, making say, $5-8M if cracks the OD roster and $2M each 15, 20, 25 HRs, for example) they I could live with Pauley-Norby platoon during next season.

Whether it is Helsley or not, a closer is a position they definitely need to address from outside the organisation.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...