Jump to content
Fish On First
  • Create Account
  • entries
    11
  • comments
    30
  • views
    45,367

Is there any hope left this offseason?


Marlins Video

As reported by Christina de Nicola, Spring Training for the 2025 season will somehow begin next week. Although pitchers and catchers begin workouts in Jupiter, FLA, there is still a considerable amount of uncertainty about Miami's roster. After Braxton Garrett was reported out of the season due to UCL surgery, the most common question is whether the FO will bring an innings-eater Starter, with potential candidates on the menu. Another approach is to bring an expensive contract from other team. Lastly, some consider (a.k.a The Ownership, apparently) that there is enough SP depth to cope with the full season. While this is clearly the most pressing need for the roster, is it the only one? Let's have a quick look at how the roster is as of today and what are the areas of improvement.

5th Starter

Let's get over it first. The current 40-man roster has 20 pitchers and 20 position players. Soon enough, the roster spots for Garrett and Pérez would be vacant, as they will be transferred to the 60-day IL. That would (hopefully) make it easier to bring some help to the arm corps: Sandy, Weathers, Cabrera, Meyer are more-or-less ticketed to begin the season in the rotation.

The front runners for that last spot are Bellozo, Mazur, Curry, and even Gillispie. After them, Snelling and Fulton are considered long shots, given lack of experience in the upper minors or recent injuries. NRIs with starter experience are Tarnok, Piña, Roa, and Monteverde. Some other Free Agents still worth a shot, at least as NRIs: Clevinger, Germán, DeSclafani, and why not Ureña or even Noah Syndergaard.

On personal note, I have no problem on letting Bellozo take the 5th spot, but maybe bringing someone on an incentive-loaded, split contract would be wise. Also, the idea of bringing an "expensive contract" is actually good, but if I'm the Yankees, D'backs, or Phillies, I would wait until late in Spring Training to get rid of them... You never know when injuries are going to come up.

Catcher

And I don't mean back-up catcher. I mean a catcher who can battle for the starting role, as I'm losing faith in Fortes. Hicks has no experience above AA, Ramírez still can't catch at MLB level, and none of the NRI group: Brantly, Mack, Ignoffo, Hostetler are a real threat to Nick. It is not a whole lot better looking at the FA list, although Grandal makes some sense.

First Base

Bride and Mervis are the only ones capable of playing the position. We don't know which version of Bride we'll get next season, and Mervis has more questions than answers during his short MLB career. As much as I like De Los Santos, he needs more seasoning in AAA to cut down his free swing. Agustín Ramírez looks more focused on playing behind the plate than to become a full-time 1B. I've already lost all faith in the Marlins giving Johnston a chance in the big leagues. Best "cheap" Free Agent available: Gavin Sheets, Rizzo... maybe José Abreu?

Glove-First SS/2B

I am convinced the Marlins should give this role to Otto López and bring a quality 3B. Even though López had a terrific second-half last season, I still don't see him as a starter. Edwards need to keep improving his defense to stick at SS. For the moment, Sanoja is the incumbent in the role, but his contributions last year were far from desirable. Acosta, Serna, and NRI Simón are behind him. If the Marlins want to bring a FA, the few options are José Iglesias, or maybe Brendan Rodgers.

This is once again wishful thinking. I don't see Bendix very much active in the Free Agent market if uncle Bruce don't open his wallet.

6 Comments


Recommended Comments

BMK3

Posted

I do not see anything about the outfield.  Maybe nobody will ever hit one to the outfield and we won't need one?

I realize that hope springs eternal, but these guys look like a dumpster fire.

One Regend

Posted

I mean this is what happens when your entire farm system is loaded with either 1B/DH prospects or prospects you will never see with an exit velocity above 85, with literally no in-between. I have no idea what Bendix's vision for talent even is, if he even has one, but it provides a bleak outlook for us. Even if Agustin Ramirez and Deyvision De Los Santos both turn into studs, we're either fielding 2 defensive messes, or clogging up the DH slot.

Hans Herrera

Posted

On 2/7/2025 at 2:45 PM, BMK3 said:

I do not see anything about the outfield.  Maybe nobody will ever hit one to the outfield and we won't need one?

I realize that hope springs eternal, but these guys look like a dumpster fire.

The thing about the outfield is that there are several players with "high hopes": Stowers, Conine, Myers, and even Mesa Jr. all have limited/none MLB experience and the organization is expecting that at least one of them develops into at least an above-replacement player.

Conine was solid last year in his cup of coffee, Myers wasn't that bad when healthy, and Jesús should stay in RF. Hill mashed LHP and played great D. There is room for improvement, yes,  but the OF is not as pressing as the other areas are.

Chad Turner

Posted

On 2/9/2025 at 11:59 PM, One Regend said:

I mean this is what happens when your entire farm system is loaded with either 1B/DH prospects or prospects you will never see with an exit velocity above 85, with literally no in-between. I have no idea what Bendix's vision for talent even is, if he even has one, but it provides a bleak outlook for us. Even if Agustin Ramirez and Deyvision De Los Santos both turn into studs, we're either fielding 2 defensive messes, or clogging up the DH slot.

I hear you.  There's more work to do before we have a perennial top 5 MiLB system like TB.  DDLS (at age 21) has time on his side to find a defensive home.  Perhaps RF is the place.  Agustin could improve at C or flipped to 3B, 1B, or COF.  We have no idea how that will work, so just be patient.  At least we aren't dealing with 27 yr old prospects like Johnston and Myers (who appeared in a few top 10 lists at the start of last year).  We have added 25 of our top 40 prospects in the last 12 months, not counting recent grads that are on the 40-man like Norby, Stowers, and Mervis (really almost everyone) who could still be late bloomers.  Not all will make it, and we can address holes in free agency the next few years,  I'd much rather be where we are now than still be a .500 club with no minors.  It had to be done.  The seeds are there, and we have better tools and personnel to tend to them now.  The path will be much clearer this Fall.  

rurrusuno

Posted

We got innings-eater guy today with Cal Quantrill. I expect him to get that third rotation spot, with Alcantara and Weathers being ahead of him. 

Hans Herrera

Posted

3 hours ago, rurrusuno said:

We got innings-eater guy today with Cal Quantrill. I expect him to get that third rotation spot, with Alcantara and Weathers being ahead of him. 

While durable, Quantril have been pretty ineffective over the last 2 years. My guess is that Cabrera should be the #3 on paper, but there is nothing for sure in this rotation except for Sandy taking the mound on Opening Day, health permitting.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...