Marlins Video
In case you missed it Miami Marlins fans, the next wave of baseball's labor wars are officially under way.
Wednesday saw the MLBPA propose something that really did nothing to address owners' concerns. Thursday saw MLB propose something that the MLBPA exists to defeat at every turn. Throughout it all, and as always in these kinds of talks, fans watched people that tend to make far more money than them put something fans love in jeopardy so those people could make even more money still.
Yep, these next six months are going to be a blast.
Obviously, no one reading this needs me to tell you that the Marlins spending more money on payroll would be a positive for the Marlins viewing experience. It's not as if MLB just proposed a salary floor without knowing all 30 teams would be able to come up with the cash. Either Marlins owner Bruce Sherman et al. are willing to do so...or they plan on selling the team really quickly to some group that will. Not hitting the floor isn't an option, provided the penalties are similar to what they are in other leagues. So no matter what, if MLB gets their way, Marlins fans win.
However, seeing as how MLB has chugged along without a salary cap to this point, it's more than fair to be skeptical about MLB getting one. The smart money remains on that not happening. Yet what does seem unavoidable is some kind of a closing of the gap between the league's rich and poor.
And if that gap does close significantly, it could finally allow the Miami Marlins to flex the greatest weapon in their player acquisition arsenal.
Miami itself.
If you think of essentially every article you've ever read about the Florida Panthers, Miami Dolphins, and Miami Heat signing a free agent, you'll recall that you spent just as much time reading about the allure of Miami and Florida's lack of state income tax than you did about space under the cap.
You never really see that talk for the Marlins though, outside of the precious few seasons they did spend aggressively, unless it is about players getting too old or playing too hurt looking for a soft landing in the sunshine. Unfortunately, the palm trees and tax free salaries don't mean much when the competition can freely outbid you to the extent the top spenders currently can.
As Will Smith once said, "you gotta have cheese for that summer house piece on South Beach." Top players are content to earn more money elsewhere, and play snowbird instead.
But if that gap is suddenly in the neighborhood of $70 million rather than $400 million? If the Marlins can market their geographic advantage to a similar extent that the Dolphins, Heat, and Panthers can? Proudly proclaiming to all free agents that Miami is decidedly, if nothing else, not Ohio? You'd better believe that is going to result in better players bringing their talents to Little Havana, just as they have to Miami, Miami Gardens, and Sunrise.
So sure, there will almost certainly continue to be teams that spend more than the Marlins. There will be smarter front offices. If first round miscues continue to happen, that third Marlins championship will probably remain as much of a pipe dream as any of the proposals just issued by the MLBPA and MLB.
The thing is though, Marlins fans don't need a guarantee of money buying a championship to benefit here. What they, and all those other fans of low payroll clubs need, is increased hope of having the chance to compete. As I've written about previously, nine of the last ten World Series winners were Top 10 in payroll. The exception was 11th. You're going to feel more confident about competing. More confident about getting more Ryan O'Hearns and less Christopher Morels.
The current MLB proposal? That would be a dream come true down here, and one that isn't happening. Any salary change though that favors the league?
It's going to result in that Miami part of their title mattering more than ever for the Miami Marlins, and that could end up being just enough to put them back in a title chase.
Will the Marlins finish with a better record in 2026 than they did in 2025?
Follow Fish On First For Miami Marlins News & Analysis
Think you could write a story like this? Fish On First wants you to develop your voice and find an audience. We recruit our paid front page writers from our users blogs section. Start a blog today!
More From Fish On First
— Latest Marlins coverage from our writers
— Recent Marlins discussion in our forums
— Become a Fish On First SuperSub








Recommended Comments
There are no comments to display.
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now