Fairbanks falters after long layoff in first blown save as Marlin

The last time Pete Fairbanks took the mound for the Miami Marlins was on April 5. He was then placed on the paternity list, activated on April 9, and he watched all the action from the bullpen during the series finale against the Cincinnati Reds, the weekend series against the Detroit Tigers and the first game against the Atlanta Braves.

Marlins manager Clayton McCullough determined in advance that Fairbanks needed to pitch on Tuesday, nine days removed from his most recent appearance. A high-leverage situation arose in the eighth inning, with the Marlins leading 5-3 and the heart of Atlanta's lineup due up. In his lone inning of work, the veteran closer was unsuccessful, surrendering three runs on three hits and taking the loss.

"He was going to pitch in that game, and when it got to that point in the eighth, I thought, 'let's go ahead and ensure that he gets his inning of work in today,' and we'd be fine in the ninth," McCullough said postgame. "It just didn't work out."

Dominic Smith, who was up at the plate with two outs in the bottom of the eighth, hit a bases-clearing double to give the Braves a 6-5 lead, their first of the game. Fairbanks threw a slider that landed right down the middle.

"I wanted that pitch," Fairbanks said. "Things didn't work out, wasn't executed properly, double in the gap. Lose a game, part of the process. That's obviously the real tough part of it, but it is what it is. I'm not going to go out there and second guess what I wanted to throw or what we wanted to throw."

This marked Fairbanks' first blown save as a member of the Marlins. For the Tampa Bay Rays last season, he converted 27 of 32 save opportunities.

Fairbanks rarely pitched in the eighth inning last season, but the Marlins made it clear that they would be utilizing him earlier in games when appropriate. This was one of those times considering that Atlanta's two most productive bats of 2026, Drake Baldwin and Matt Olson, were due to come to the plate.

The bigger issue here is that the Marlins threw Fairbanks into this important spot coming off such an extended stretch of inactivity. He was not in a position to perform up to his usual standards.

Fairbanks' fastball topped out at 98.3 mph, averaged 96.7 mph and generated four whiffs. Of his 26 pitches, 19 of them landed for strikes. Fairbanks believed that his release points weren't exactly where they were supposed to be, resulting in pitches up in the zone, but he was pleased with the overall shapes.

"Go to bed, try not to take it with you," Fairbanks said regarding his mentality following a blown save. "You get mad for a little bit, then you let it go and you show up and do your job the next day."

On a positive note, the Marlins offense picked up right where they left off on Monday, combining for nine total hits. In the top of the first inning, the Fish attacked Reynaldo Lopez right away with a sacrifice fly from Agustín Ramírez.

In the following inning, Connor Norby laced an RBI single, extending his hitting streak to seven games. Atlanta native Graham Pauley smacked his fifth double of the season, driving in Norby. Jakob Marsee secured a multi-hit game on an RBI single, giving Miami a commanding 4-0 lead through just two innings.

Max Meyer for a second straight start gave the Marlins five innings of work, allowing three runs on five hits, one walk and struck out five. He averaged 16.4 pitches per inning, topping out at 21 in the second and 20 in the fifth. In the bottom of the third inning, he surrendered back-to-back RBI doubles to Baldwin and Olson.

Surprisingly, Meyer's sweeper was his most-used pitch on Tuesday instead of his slider. Throwing the sweeper 26% of the time, he generated six whiffs, including a swinging strikeout of Mauricio Dubón in the bottom of the fifth.

Meyer remains the only Marlins starting pitcher who has not surpassed five innings pitched this season.

In the eighth, Otto Lopez added an RBI single to give Fairbanks some breathing room, but it wasn't enough as things turned out.

The Marlins drop to 9-9 on the season, now looking for the series win on Wednesday at 7:15 pm with Chris Paddack on the mound.