Riddle me this, Miami Marlins fans.
What do Tim Anderson, Pete Fairbanks, John King, Christopher Morel, Chris Paddack, Cal Quantrill, Austin Slater, and Eric Wagaman all have in common?
Big disappointment? Not worth the money? Signed by Peter Bendix? Close, but no cigar. None of them were good first basemen? Funny, but also no. They all looked good in teal? I mean, who wouldn't, but some of them didn't even get the privilege.
No, I'm afraid the answer we were looking for was all of them were signed to one-year deals.
That unfortunate collection of talent represents the entirety of the Marlins forays into free agency since Peter Bendix started running the show. You have to go all the way back to Jean Segura in 2023 for the last time Miami offered two years to a free agent. In fairness, you could see how that particular transaction might have left a bad taste in Bruce Sherman's mouth.
New Fish On First LIVE tonight! Making sense of the Marlins rumors that are out there so far and simulating one version of what a full, successful offseason would look like. 📺 Join us at 7:00 PM 🤝 Presented by https://t.co/5VSVRB2VIi (code: FISHONFIRST)
— Fish On First Podcast (@FishOnFirstPod) November 10, 2026
Come to think of it, it doesn't get much better if you go even further back. Of Miami's last five multi-year free-agent signings, your WAR winners are Anthony Bass and Jorge Soler, tied at 1.8 Marlins War apiece. Corey Dickerson at least delivered positive value, whereas the best that can be said of Segura is he was part of the Josh Bell trade that helped Miami reach the playoffs in 2023. Although, seeing as how Bell exercised his $16.5 million option for 2024, it's likely Marlins ownership doesn't share that sentiment. As for that fifth multi-year free agent, enough has been written about Avisail Garcia to fill several depressing books.
Consequently, you can understand Sherman's reluctance to go that extra year.
However, it's also hard to argue that Miami's preference for one-year deals hasn't been a limiting factor for the club in free agency. There's only a certain caliber of player willing to take that kind of offer. Success stories there are few and far between and the Marlins haven't been finding them.
Could that change under a salary cap?
That's the big question for Miami this offseason. Will the team finally be willing to go that extra year?
There's a compelling case for yes, if for no other reason than the fact next season's Marlins are expected to compete. That alone should be worthy of special reinforcement. Beyond that though is the prospect of MLB finally getting that cap and the resulting need of Miami having to significantly expand payroll.
If Miami has to spend more anyway, why not be willing to offer players that extra year? Among active Marlins, only Sandy Alcantara has a guaranteed contract for 2027. No one does for 2028. Even if there is no cap, there's never been a better time for Miami to roll the dice on a longer-term commitment. That doesn't have to mean breaking the bank for top of the market talent either. Only that the Marlins shouldn't recoil if a second year, or even just an option for one, is required to get a deal done with a solid player.
The time has come for Miami to modestly change their approach. Hopefully, the time has also come for them to finally pick the right player.
Will the Marlins sign any of their players to contract extensions this offseason?
Follow Fish On First For Miami Marlins News & Analysis
Think you could write a story like this? Fish On First wants you to develop your voice and find an audience. We recruit our paid front page writers from our users blogs section. Start a blog today!
More From Fish On First
— Latest Marlins coverage from our writers
— Recent Marlins discussion in our forums
— Become a Fish On First SuperSub







Recommended Comments
There are no comments to display.
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now