Marlins receive: OF Jo Adell
Angels receive: 3B/DH Jacob Berry (MIA #21 prospect) and RHP Josh White
Jo Adell gives the Marlins a super high upside project for the new MLB staff to work with. Adell is coming off a 90 wRC+ 0.1 fWAR season in 130 games but a heap of mental errors and unluckiness on batted balls ( .317 xwOBA vs .296 wOBA) brought his production down in 2024. But he was been progressing his game throughout his MLB career and has 3 more years of club control.
Berry while starting to finally looked like the #6 overall pick that he was selected to be still lacks true upside due to his lack of overall power and abysmal defense. White is coming off a strong 3.02 ERA season mostly as a reliver at the A+ he is nothing more than a sweetener in this deal.
Marlins receive: RHP Jaden Hamm (DET #7 prospect), 2B Max Anderson (DET #17 prospect)
Tigers receive: LHP Braxton Garrett
The MLB pitching market appears to be scorching hot with Montas and Boyd getting bloated deals. The Marlins should take advantage of this. Unfortunately this means parting ways with a former first round pick, But they have the depth especially for an inbetween year to look ahead to the future
Hamm is coming off an electric 2.64 ERA campaign over 99 IP at the A+ level. He boasts an elctric fastball that sits low to mid 90s with insane ride that carried him to one of the best K%-BB% at the A+ level last year. Anderson is a solid "just put the ball in play" that can hopefully fill some organizational depth and maybe become an MLB bench bat
Marlins receive: OF Jhostynxon Garcia (BOS #12 prospect) and OF Allan Castro (BOS #19 prospect)
Red Sox receive: RHP Edward Cabrera and RHP Anthony Bender
Jhostynxon 'The Password' Garcia is coming off a super strong .892 OPS season between A, A+ and AA. Although his walk rate outside of A ball leaves a lot to be desired (5.1 BB%) he makes up for this by swinging early and often and makes consistent quality contact while elevating and looks to be an intriguing addition to a future MLB OF. Allan Castro is almost the opposite; he lacks Garcia's raw tools he makes up for it with a sparkling 14 BB% and 14 homers.
For Edward Cabrera, frustration after years of noty being able to locate the zone has warranted letting another team take a chance on a super high upside arm. He could also benefit a lot from thier heavy sinker philosiphy. His sinker out performed his 4seam by .038 xwOBA and gave up 6 HRs on the 4seam vs only 1 on the sinker. Bender has been an above average RP for a couple years with the Marlins but to take a chance at a future starting corner OF, it's worth the value
Marlins receive: RHP Jaxon Wiggins (CHC #10 prospect) and OF Jonathon Long (CHC #28 prospect)
Cubs receive: RHP Calvin Faucher
Calvin Faucher after being attached in the Vidal Brujan trade now looks like the center piece. He posted a spectacular 3.19 ERA and 2.50 FIP as well as becoming the defacto closer post deadline. However, relievers are replacble and I don't believe the team is ready to compete yet so we're going to sell high on a stellar late inning arm.
In return the Fish will get a hard throwing pitcher who struggles to find the zone at times in Jaxon Wiggins and a super underrated bat in Jonathon Long. Wiggins despite control issues posted 28.0K% and .194 BAA. At the very least his heater and slider should allow him to fill in the 'pen if he fails to stick as a starter. Long is a bat only prospect to put it bluntly. Due to his 30 grade speed and 5'11 stature he's an awkward fit for anywhere on the diamond but at the plate he slashed .283/.391/461 for a 149 wRC+ between A+ and AA. The key components to his success offensively are his plate discipline (14.1 BB%) and his power (17 HR and 38 XBH) in in a 489 PA sample size
Marlins recevie: RHP Gavin Williams
Guardians receive: OF Victor Mesa Jr and RHP Juan De La Cruz
Gavin Williams will be a solid answer to be in the backend of the rotation while it recovers from the hit it would take in this exercise after Cabrera and Garrett are gone. He's a solid 4 currently with possible upside of a low end 3. For us he will be the backend guy to provide consistant starts. While VMJ is a long time marlins fan favorite prospect due to his +glove and speed I'm not sure how his game will translate to the next level since he struggles so much agasinst velo. Juan De La Cruz is a semi-interesting lower level prospect with some interesting characteristics that Cleaveland may like
The Leading Moments to the Sherman era
After decades of being renowned as possibly THE worst owner in MLB after sinking baseball in 2 cities and 2 different countries (Miami and Montreal) Jeffery Loria finally decided he had enough of dealing with a begrudged fanbase and a running in place baseball team, he made the decision that lit a spark in all south Florida baseball fans' eyes. He decided to sell the team. During the process there became two front runners: Jorge Mas and Bruce Sherman. Jorge Mas was an eccentric billionaire who had already had his hands in Miami Sports. Sherman was the gritty half billionaire that had two aces up his sleeve. An at the time future HoF SS in Derek Jeter and an extra $30 Million dollars he was willing to to throw down to purchase the team.
On the 2nd of October 2017 the deal was done and the ink was set to dry. Bruce Sherman had become the next owner of the Miami Marlins. When he arrived both he and Jeter were barraged with questions over why and how they would be able to right the ship of a lost at sea franchise. The moniker of the regime quicky became that this isn't a rebuild, we're building this team and it'll be done through waves and waves of talent that will surface through the farm system.
The Opening Moves
In his first offseason with the team with Jeter in charge of baseball operations was to trade current MLB stars for prospects hand selected by Jeter himself. This was originally met with controversy from the fans and media because it appeared to be just another fire sale in which the Marlins are practically synonymous with, but we were reassured that this will be the right move. The real controversy was after the players had become aware of Derek Jeter's plans. The stars of the team became openly frustrated with the situation which ultimately lead to all 4 of our young superstars to be dealt in the next 16 months, 3 of which would take place in this 2017 offseason.
The new regimes first offseason resulted in trading reigning MVP Giancarlo Stanton to the Yankees for 2B Starlin Castro, INF prospect Jose Devers, and pitching prospect Jorge Guzman. Marcell Ozuna to the Cardinals for SP Sandy Alcantara, SP Zac Gallen, CF Magneuris Sierra, SP Daniel Castano. Christian Yelich to the Brewers for CF Lewis Brinson, CF Monte Harrison, INF Isan Diaz SP Jordan Yamamoto, Dee Gordon and IFA money to the Mariners for SP Nick Neidert, SP Robert Duggar, INF Christopher Torres and I saved the first trade for last SP prospect Michael King and IFA money for 1B Garrett Cooper and SP Caleb Smith.
This offseason really set the stage and the future did seem bright. Many of the prospects like Lewis Brinson and Sandy Alcantara were regarded very highly by the national media. It felt like only a matter of time until Miami fans would see good baseball once again.
The Fruits Of Their Labor
By the end of the 2019 season the fans had endured 2 more losing seasons with a combined record of 120-203. But that was part of the plan and most fans knew that. But as long as they amassed talent that would be the faces of future teams it seemed worth our time investment. As the 2019 team settled They were praised for becoming one of the most talented minor league systems in baseball.
Let's categorize the prospects based on how they were acquired to get a better understanding in how much the Marlins themselves are responsible for each player's development.
The biggest prospects they traded for were: Lewis Brinson, Monte Harrison, Isan Diaz, Sandy Alcantara, Zac Gallen, Jazz Chisholm Jr, Jesus Sanchez, Lewin Diaz, Jorge Alfaro, Sixto Sanchez, Nick Neidert, Jose Devers. Out of these groups of players only 4 are every day starters, and 2 of them are in the upper crust of the league and 1 of those players was traded in his rookie year for only a good player and not the elite talent that Gallen has become.
Most of these hitting prospects came up with other orgs until they were in the upper minors then all showed very similar flaws when they got to the Marlins and to the MLB level. Swing and miss, Chasing bad pitches and an inability to hit the ball at advantageous angles with power. To trade for eight different players that would grace popular top 100 prospects lists and to only get three players to become roster-able players is un utter embarrassment.
Maybe we can try to give them grace and hope they were just taken advantage of in trades and let's see how the hand selected homegrown talents have turned out.
Since the first draft under the new regime only 4 position players or starting pitchers have been drafted, signed, developed and debuted for the Marlins. That's right! In 6 years of drafts they've only managed to find themselves 4 possible starters for the future. Those 4 being Nick Fortes, JJ Bleday, Peyton Burdick, and Max Meyer.
Fortes has been an intriguing defense only backup catcher, JJ Bleday struggled through out his minor league career and was traded to Oakland where he finally turned the corner, Peyton Burdick has 139 career PA's with a 38.1 K% and Max Meyer is recently recovered from TJ and look more like a middle innings reliever than a future corner stone in the rotation that he was built up to be.
The international free agency side is probably where the most amount of expanded investment has taken place, with an academy built in the Dominican Republic and more money pumped in to the behind the scenes at the lowest levels of minor league baseball. Their top investments have been in Victor Victor mesa, Victor Mesa Jr, Jose Salas, Yiddi Cappe, Junior Sanchez, Ian Lewis. The only one that looks promising of the group Is Victor Mesa Jr. But they were able to find a crown jewel in the rough in RHP Eury Perez who looks to be one of the top pitchers in baseball at just 22 years old. UTIL Javier Sanoja also looks like a possible MLB caliber player but lacks a true upside that makes him hard to project him to be an everyday player.
The Minor League System Overview
Under Jeter/Denbo/Kim one thing became known amongst Marlins fans and the league. The Marlins do not know how to develop hitting at all, and became one of the worst in practically every important metric. As time marched forward every cry you'd hear from Marlins fans were cries for bats. All of the once vaunted prospects had all flamed out and either had been traded or have since retired from baseball or still fighting for their careers outside of affiliated ball. The pitching side of things has seen a decent amount of success with Sandy, Gallen, Lopez, Garrett, Rogers, Perez and Luzardo but very few had been developed at the minor league level with the Marlins.
The most frustrating part was watching almost every highly regarded prospect or fresh draftee slowly fade into irrelevance the longer they spent in the organization. The 2019 draft in particular looked like an absolute slam dunk with Kameron Misner, Peyton Burdick and JD Orr exploding out of the gate and then proceeded to greatly decline and show bigger and bigger flaws in their games as they advanced through the minor leagues. Then the absolutely dreadful part was the excitement for new bats in the system to immediately flop. JJ Bleday, Connor Scott, Joe Mack, Kahlil Watson were all first round picks that either immediately struggled or flashed warning signs of their potential may not have been what it was cracked up to be.
The Deficiencies In Team Building
One of my biggest qualms with the organization Pre Peter Bendix was how the assets were managed. The two biggest flaws of how the roster was managed came from their handling of veterans. With few exceptions practically every free agent signing was an absolute bust for the Fish. Corey Dickerson, Avisail Garcia and Jean Segura were all negatives for the team with Garcia and Segura being some of the worst players in baseball in their with the fish.
My other annoyance with the team had been the refusal to trade veterans who had no future with the team. Namely Miguel Rojas, Jesus Aguilar and Starlin Castro, were all held on to for far too long and were either released or traded for very little in return. Good teams realize when a player isn't going to get them any closer to the playoffs or a championship and trade them for younger players that can hopefully be a part of future successful teams. With the only caveat being you have to select the right players and you need to give them the right tools and guidance to become successful MLB players which simply did not happen under the Jeter/NG regimes.
The Peter Bendix Era And The Role Analytics Plays In Baseball
From an outsiders perspective many claim that the Marlins threw away a playoff team and new GM Peter Bendix has ran the team into the ground to become one of the worst teams in baseball. While on the surface this is technically true, those of us who have followed the entire organization throughout the the Sherman's ownership have been pointing out signs of rot that have been emanating up and down the Marlins system. The lack of developing hitters and trading away pitchers and prospects to make up for 7 years of failures had left the organization rotting from the inside. There has been no future for a while now and I have been pounding the table for a rebuild for a couple years now and I finally have my wish.
After the first season under Peter Bendix he has also come to the conclusion that this organization needs a complete makeover if they ever want to be a serious competitor. His main goal was to once again trade MLB players for prospects of his choosing. However, this time he did not have a reigning MVP and three superstar hitters to trade away. He was handed down good role players but not a single true star or superstar. Nonetheless he was able to deal 11 MLB players for 20 prospects. While like the previous regime you can see them chasing high upside players with obvious faults like De Los Santos, Jun-Seok Shim many of his new prospects are guys that have made a name for themselves based on good plate discipline, swing decisions and optimal launch angles like Jakob Marsee, Jared Serna and Agustin Ramirez.
The other interesting pattern the ability to acquire decent players for next to nothing. Otto Lopez, Jonah Bride, and Declan Cronin are 3 prime examples of such and they all fall into a similar bucket "Sabermetric Darlings" Otto Lopez is an elite defender with around a league average bat with ++ base running, Jonah Bride is a the perfect example of how pulling flyballs will get you good results and Declan Cronin managed a 2.58 FIP and didn't surrender a homerun until mid September.
Peter has secretly told us some of his thoughts on the previous regime and his own philosophies in a very secretive manner. Throughout his trades and the draft he brought in 29 bats and only 12 arms. It clear that he saw the talent level and protypes of hitters in the org and knew there needed to be a change. He also told us how the actual development process should be ran. He has fired most of the baseball ops employees he inherited and has insisted on getting as many of his own guys in house and as many people in house as he can to help with the development of prospects. As former senior analyst of the Marlins Bradley Woodrum stated there used to be only three people made up the analytics department at one point. He later stated that he believes that Bendix wants there to be about 40. A 13x increase in personnel sounds astonishing until you realize the gap of success that the Rays (Bendix's last team) and the Marlins success at drafting and developing MLB caliber players.
Only time will be able to tell us about how this new experiment will end up, but i for one am supremely confident in Peter Bendix's ability to build an organization and future successful MLB teams.
