Fish On First's 2023 Miami Marlins award selections

At the end of an 84-win Miami Marlins regular season and right before the start of their postseason run, I surveyed the Fish On First staff about which players have been most responsible for helping the team get to this point.

Submit your own 2023 award selections in the comments!

Isaac Azout

Marlins MVP: Luis Arráez

Pitcher of the year: Braxton Garrett

Most surprising player: Andrew Nardi

Most disappointing player: Nick Fortes

Reliever of the year: Tanner Scott

Comeback player of the year: Jesús Sánchez

Best trade acquisition: Jake Burger

MiLB player of the year: Troy Johnston

2024 free agent/trade target: Johnny Cueto

Kevin Barral

Marlins MVP: Luis Arráez

Pitcher of the year: Braxton Garrett

Most surprising player: Jesús Sánchez

Most disappointing player: Edward Cabrera

Reliever of the year: Tanner Scott

Comeback player of the year: Jorge Soler

Best trade acquisition: Jake Burger

MiLB player of the year: Troy Johnston

2024 free agent/trade target: Mitch Garver

Hector Rodriguez

Marlins MVP: Luis Arráez

Pitcher of the year: Jesús Luzardo

Most surprising player: Garrett Hampson

Most disappointing player: A.J. Puk

Reliever of the year: Tanner Scott

Comeback player of the year: Jorge Soler

Best trade acquisition: Jake Burger

MiLB player of the year: Troy Johnston

2024 free agent/trade target: Salvador Pérez

Ely Sussman

Marlins MVP: Luis Arráez

Pitcher of the year: Braxton Garrett

Most surprising player: Tanner Scott

Most disappointing player: Joey Wendle

Reliever of the year: Tanner Scott

Comeback player of the year: Jorge Soler

Best trade acquisition: Jake Burger

MiLB player of the year: Troy Johnston

2024 free agent/trade target: Mitch Garver

Daniel Rodriguez

Marlins MVP: Luis Arráez

Pitcher of the year: Tanner Scott

Most surprising player: Braxton Garrett

Most disappointing player: David Robertson

Reliever of the year: Tanner Scott

Comeback player of the year: Jorge Soler

Best trade acquisition: Jake Burger

MiLB player of the year: Troy Johnston

2024 free agent/trade target: Teoscar Hernández/Alex Wood/Lucas Giolito

Louis Addeo-Weiss

Marlins MVP: Jorge Soler

Pitcher of the year: Braxton Garrett

Most surprising player: Jon Berti

Most disappointing player: Avísaíl García

Reliever of the year: Tanner Scott

Comeback player of the year: Jorge Soler

Best trade acquisition: Jake Burger

MiLB player of the year: Troy Johnston

2024 free agent/trade target: Aaron Nola—you need innings whether Sandy is healthy or not, and Nola is as durable as they come.

Alex Krutchik

Marlins MVP: Luis Arráez

Pitcher of the year: Braxton Garrett

Most surprising player: Braxton Garrett

Most disappointing player: David Robertson

Reliever of the year: Tanner Scott

Comeback player of the year: Jorge Soler

Best trade acquisition: Jake Burger

MiLB player of the year: Troy Johnston

2024 free agent/trade target: Michael Lorenzen

Noah Berger

Marlins MVP: Luis Arráez

Pitcher of the year: Braxton Garrett

Most surprising player: Garrett Hampson

Most disappointing player: Sandy Alcantara

Reliever of the year: Tanner Scott

Comeback player of the year: Jorge Soler

Best trade acquisition: Jake Burger

MiLB player of the year: Xavier Edwards

2024 free agent/trade target: Zack Gelof (for the vibes)

Alex Carver

Marlins MVP: Luis Arráez

Pitcher of the year: Braxton Garrett

Most surprising player: Garrett Hampson

Most disappointing player: Jacob Stallings

Reliever of the year: Tanner Scott

Best trade acquisition: Jake Burger

MiLB player of the year: Troy Johnston

2024 free agent/trade target: Gleyber Torres

Photo courtesy of Miami Marlins